Sandwich RestaurantFast Food RestaurantRestaurantTake Out RestaurantCatererSubway
Your local Bonifay Subway® Restaurant at 1818 S Waukesha St brings bold new flavors and classic favorites to guests every day. Enjoy our famous Footlongs, 6" sandwiches, wraps, and salads, ordered quickly in the app or online, through convenient delivery, in-restaurant dining, or curbside pickup. We’re proud to offer a fresh alternative to typical fast food with fresh-cut veggies, tasty proteins, fresh-baked bread, and delicious cookies. We’re also here for your catering needs. All Subway® Restaurants are independently owned and operated by business owners who employ talented Sandwich Artists™.
Customer experiences with service were mixed, with some praising friendly and efficient staff, while others reported rude and unprofessional behavior.
Food Quality
Many customers enjoyed the freshness and taste of the food, although there were complaints about specific items being poorly prepared or lacking in ingredients.
Cleanliness
The cleanliness of the location received positive feedback, but there were also reports of unsanitary conditions in some instances.
Wait Times
Customers frequently mentioned long wait times, especially during busy periods, which affected their overall experience.
TS
Thomas Savioli
Dec 18, 2025
1.0
Weird. Did an online order when I got there they said it was voided, but I clearly had proof that it was ordered and showed it was taken out of my account. The guy said it would be refunded to my card. Well, it wasn’t and the transaction was 100% processed, so now I have to dispute it on my card. Weird and scammy
RG
Roger G
Dec 2, 2025
1.0
Worst sub ive ever had! Couldn't even eat it.bread was stale taste was totally off and bad!!