The NY Pizza Place - Boca Raton

Reviews

• MG

  Myoski Glover

  2 days ago
  5.0
  I really enjoyed the pizza from this shop. The ingredients tasted very fresh and the pizza had great flavor. The crust was baked perfectly and the toppings were evenly spread. The cheese melted smoothly and the sauce had a rich taste. The staff were friendly and attentive.
• DD

  Dustin

  3 days ago
  1.0
  An hour for slices! Then a plus-size employee — who was coughing into her hands — grabbed herself a soda and a slice out of the display case (using her hands to separate the slice) while on FaceTime the entire time. All without washing her hands. I walked in and was told it would be about 10 minutes before they had slices available. I waited 20 minutes, went back to the counter, and was told it would be another 15 minutes because a large order had been placed. So apparently if you place a large order, you jump to the front of the line. The young woman working the front counter was very nice and helpful, so this isn’t about her — but the overall experience was disappointing and concerning from a food-safety standpoint.
• NR

  N Romo

  Mar 28, 2026
  4.0
  I always order pizza from here whenever I’m having people over or my kids friends. In December I spent over 400 on pizza for my son’s bday. If my son wants a slice I will go by. Tonight I went in and the guy behind the counter was on his ear buds talking. He then asked if I picking up. I said no and he then told me to “Talk”. I ordered 5 slices. He pointed at the card swipe to pay and didn’t tell me the price. He threw them in the oven for 5 seconds and pilled them into a small box on top of each other. I pay with points a lot because I have spent so much money there. I wasn’t given the opportunity to or even apply the purchase to my account.
• RH

  Richard Huling

  Mar 27, 2026
  2.0
  This place has gone all the way down the hill. Used to be good when they first opened. Pizza doesn't taste the same and service is horrible. All 3 customers ordering pickup were clearly upset. One lady asking for a managers number. Another lady got given a whole Sicilian Pizza unsliced after they left it open on the counter for 10 minutes. And then I get home and one of my whole pies was unsliced! Extremely poor management apparently. I'm only giving a 2 star because they used to be good. It's really a 1 star at this point.
• JL

  Juan Lopez

  Mar 22, 2026
  1.0
  First the price of $67.10 for a large pie and two salads and two waters was just absolutely absurd for this type of atmosphere and pizza will never go back to this place. This is like another Little Caesars with two tables to sit down and eat terrible.