Numerous customers reported slow service, inattentive staff, and long wait times for food and drinks.
Food Quality
Many reviews highlighted inconsistent food quality, with complaints about overcooked wings, incorrect orders, and cold meals.
Staff Performance
While some servers received praise for their friendliness and attentiveness, others were criticized for poor attitudes and lack of professionalism.
Management Concerns
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with management's handling of service issues and overall restaurant operations.
Positive Experiences
Despite the negative feedback, some customers enjoyed the food and atmosphere, particularly praising specific servers and menu items.
FB
Free Bird
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
Great spot for wings and beer. Typically there once a week and blazin rewards come in handy.
HC
Him Chu
Dec 29, 2025
2.0
Food good as always, and waitress was nice. Worked in the service industry so I know it can be difficult on busy nights. Regardless though, restaurant looked mildly busy, but just saw workers literally on their phone on the floor. Just a bad look. Looked like a kid maybe 18 outside who worked there outside smoking, also not a good look on them. Server was the only person who managed all the bar tables and helping her friend at the bar. However that doesn’t effect the fact that the kitchen on a regular night took more than 20 minutes to bring out a cookie skillet that we don’t wait around for as they forgot to even put it on our bill. 3 staff also just standing there in the doorway doing what looked to be noting for more than 5 minutes. There were also several tables the staff neglected to clean up. Either a management problem understaffing as it is 4 days after holidays or just lazy employees. It’s a bad look to put on a good restaurant with quality food everytime I’ve been. Employees looked as if they could care less. One floor employee looked stoned just walking around on the phone. I just wish they would have a better look on these establishments to make sure they are best for every customer so they don’t get worse reviews than mine. I’ve never had such a bad restaurant experience. That being said I don’t think anyone working there is a bad employee, everyone always has off nights, but when in the serving customers industry , that is not do them to know. Handle that away from customers.
FB
Filomena Bartolotti
Dec 22, 2025
5.0
Always great wings when you dine in
MC
Matt C
Dec 14, 2025
5.0
I visited on a busy football Sunday, service was surprisingly very fast and food was great! All the games were on too.
TD
Trina DeMaio
Dec 1, 2025
2.0
It’s Monday night we stopped by for a little dinner the place was pretty empty even though Monday night football was on! Our server was awesome. But the food ????!!!? My buffalo chicken ranch wrap was awful!!! Cold hard chicken only 1 chicken strip for the whole wrap! Cut into chunks to look like more! no buffalo sauce or ranch a pound of shredded cheese and two little bits of lettuce!!!!!! It sucked!!! Our fries were cold and soft! We will not be returning to this place!!
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Middletown offer?
Buffalo Wild Wings offers award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with 26 sauces and seasonings choices.
Where is Buffalo Wild Wings located in Middletown, DE?
Buffalo Wild Wings is located at 540 West Main Street, Middletown, DE 19709, USA.
What are the opening hours of Buffalo Wild Wings in Middletown?
Buffalo Wild Wings is open Monday through Thursday and Sunday from 11:00 AM to 11:00 PM, and on Friday and Saturday from 11:00 AM to midnight.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings in Middletown currently open?
Buffalo Wild Wings is currently open and operational.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings Middletown by phone?
You can call Buffalo Wild Wings at +1 302-285-0000 for inquiries or reservations.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings Middletown have an official website?
Yes, Buffalo Wild Wings Middletown's official website is https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/de/middletown/540-west-main-street/sports-bar-507/
What types of services does Buffalo Wild Wings Middletown provide?
Buffalo Wild Wings Middletown functions as a chicken wings restaurant, sports bar, and takeout restaurant.
Are there any ATMs near Buffalo Wild Wings Middletown?
Yes, the WSFS ATM and Bank of America ATM are nearby, convenient for withdrawing cash before or after your visit.
What other dining options are near Buffalo Wild Wings in Middletown?
Nearby dining options include Wayback Burgers for burgers, Sushi Yama for Japanese cuisine, Jersey Mike's Subs for sandwiches, Waffle House for breakfast, and Ruby Tuesday for American food.
What nearby services can I access around Buffalo Wild Wings Middletown?
You can find services such as Lowe's Home Improvement and The Home Depot for hardware supplies, Cochran Liquors for drinks, 9Round Fitness gym, Kingdom Spa 2 for skincare, and Verizon mobile phone store nearby.