Salty Tomato Pizza

Reviews

• MF

  Michelle Ferro

  4 days ago
  5.0
  Salty Tomato is one of our favorites! Everything is always fresh and delicious. From subs, salads, dinners, pizza, stuffed bread, etc. Chef Niko and his staff always deliver the best food at great prices. Try their family meal deals! I guarantee you'll need to look for an excuse to cook!
• CL

  Christine Limone

  5 days ago
  1.0
  My husband ordered two grinders over the phone and explicitly said No peppers and mentioned his food allergies. Went and picked our order Got home guess what- red peppers on his grinder. Just called to speak with someone to make this right. Their posted hours say they’re open for another 30 minutes and no one is answering the phone. Do better
• JD

  Jim Donegan

  5 days ago
  5.0
  **** FOOD REVIEW*** OMG!!!! We just got the family deal from @Salty tomatoes Baybrook Shopping Ctr. All this food for $39.. The BEST!!! Chicken Parm, ziti, Ceasars salad and garlic knots. This will easily feed 4 people. If you haven't tried this place yet get down there. You wont regret it... P.S. I also had the best calzone from there the other day as well.. batting 1,000!! 👍👍
• JR

  Jacques Rossignol

  Feb 18, 2026
  5.0
  My first time there with the new ownership. Service was fast and super friendly. They did an outstanding job remodeling. Chicken Parmesan dinner was outstanding. Super fresh tasting with a great sauce and fresh basil. Even the side salad was impressive, Not your usual local watery lettuce salad with one olive one tomato, and a few slices of carrot like most of the places in town. West Haven needed a new breath of fresh air Italian restaurant like this place.
• MC

  Maria Colbert

  Feb 14, 2026
  5.0
  An absolute must visit! Everything from start to finish deserves a 5 out of 5. Garlic Knots, light and airy served with a robust tomato basil sauce. Margherita red pizza, with the perfect amount of sauce to cheese ratio, the basil oil adds a delicate touch. My Husband gave 2 thumbs up for the House Sicilian, and to top it off the Nutella with Strawberry pizza was to die for!!!! If you have not visited yet, you definitely have to try it immediately. You will not be disappointed!