Gaetano's Tavern On Main

Reviews

• JT

  Jason Tran

  Apr 18, 2026
  5.0
  I came here because I heard that they had the best fries and those thick cut fries ended up being fantastic. The waitress told me their most popular item was the pot roast. I was skeptical but I ordered it anyways and what I ate was the best pot roast that I have ever had. It was actually tender and the gravy on top was nice. The gravy also went well with the fries that I ordered earlier. The waitress was really attentive and I had no issues with the service.
• DC

  David Cullen

  Apr 11, 2026
  5.0
  I ordered fried scallops and a mushroom appetizer to go (delivery). The food was excellent, delivered hot, and the portions were huge. And they've got the best coleslaw that I've had in a long time. (Note this was delivery, so the "atmosphere" is my living room lol).
• MP

  Mason Powers

  Mar 25, 2026
  5.0
  Went here for dinner with my parents the other night and we all left saying, “we will be back!” Gaetano’s has that perfect hometown, feel good vibe you hope to find. The portions are generous, and you can tell the food is made with care. The service was personable and attentive without being over the top, which made the whole experience even better. We also loved the cozy tavern feel inside… it just makes you want to sit back, relax, and enjoy your meal. Highly recommend and definitely looking forward to coming back!
• AS

  aron sylvan

  Mar 19, 2026
  5.0
  Gaetano's has a variety of food and drink options and is very consistent.
• TA

  Taylor Allen

  Mar 15, 2026
  5.0
  Last minute meet up with my sister we ended up here! I was gonna go across the street to knuckleheads but my sister wanted brunch. Jackie greeted us when we walked in & seated up immediately. We were the first table in. Although the bar is darker we wanted a booth so that’s where we sat in the back it was very comfortable. I was really tempted on the bottomless brunch, but was driving unfortunately! I ordered the egg fiesta & my sister got the egg quesadilla! She ate all hers. I was so full I took half of mine home. It was delicious! Can’t wait to come back. If we had eaten dinner it would have been more like 30 a person. Since we had brunch it was just under 20 pp. Thanks Jackie for the Awesome service!

Frequently Asked Questions About Gaetano's Tavern On Main