Customers frequently praised the burgers and milkshakes for being delicious and freshly made.
Service
The staff, particularly the manager Lori, received high marks for being friendly, welcoming, and attentive to customers.
Cleanliness
Many reviews highlighted the cleanliness of the restaurant, including the dining area and bathrooms.
Pricing
Some customers felt the prices were high for the food quality, while others considered it fair for the experience.
Atmosphere
The restaurant was described as having a pleasant and inviting atmosphere, making it a good stop for travelers.
MR
Myshell Ross
Nov 14, 2025
3.0
They are extremely slow for a fast food place . It took them a hour to do a $8 meal which comes with a single burger and some fries . If your on your 30 minute lunch break DONT GO HERE
MK
Michael Kerr
Oct 26, 2025
5.0
We stopped in on our way to and from a soccer tournament and we were very happy with everything. The food was hot and fresh. The service was great. The building is a bit small, so not great for big groups. Everything was clean, including the bathrooms. There was plenty of parking each time we stopped. We will gladly be going back the next time we are passing through!
NL
Nathan Lapointe
Oct 24, 2025
2.0
Stopped in on my way home from a long drive, my wife and I had already gone past dinner time and needed some re fuel. It was conveniently placed pretty close to the highway not more then a mile off. So no issue with getting off and back on. The area from the outside looked really nice well groomed even. Maybe that's because of the area more then just a franchise standard. Now when we got inside the girl at the register was dismissive, impatient, and did not want to be there at all. We maintained a friendly attitude and just continued to order. Although I definitely felt her frustration for us being there as if we bothered her in some way. And to clarify it was around 630 pm so not near closing at all. My wife and I were the only ones in there as well. So non the less we received the food, it came in a tray although we asked for it to go. When we asked for boxes she rolled her eyes and went back behind the counter to get them. That alone actually took her a good 5 minutes. While she was doing that I had asked for a sauce to go with my wife's order she had forgotten to ask. I went to another employee since the gal was still getting the box. He wasn't any kinder when he responded, verbally goes and makes a bothersome sigh, as he states yeah I guess I could. Now I'm like what on earth is up with this place. Does everyone here act like this all the time? And not for nothing... It was almost 40 dollars for 2 burgers, a small fry to share, and one shared drink. I could have gone to a nice sit down burger joint and gotten twice the quality with out half the headache. So on that note.. would I recommend this place.. no. Not at all would it be worth your time to try it at least once in your life. Maybe find another location because in my opinion the food was just okay. The service made this place a 10 out of 10 will not go to again. I wish I had something better to say but I can't change the experience. I did how ever tell them all to have a great day when we left in hopes some positive energy might even help w.e. dysfunction they are working with over there to drive such a poor attitude.
GG
Gav
Aug 21, 2025
5.0
Food was great. Highly recommend the bourbon burger and the fried pickles. Our server Yareth was great.
EC
Ellen C
Aug 19, 2025
5.0
Randomly took a highway exit when traveling home from Cape Cod and stumbled upon Wayback Burgers. The burger was freshly cooked and delicious. The fries were quite good as well. The wait staff was so pleasant. Wayback Burgers was a good find!
Wayback Burgers is a fast-casual burger joint serving fresh burgers, hand-dipped milkshakes, hot dogs, and chicken sandwiches.
What are the operating hours of Wayback Burgers in Old Saybrook?
Wayback Burgers is open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Can I order delivery or pickup from Wayback Burgers?
Yes, Wayback Burgers offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
What payment methods are accepted at Wayback Burgers?
They accept American Express, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Where is Wayback Burgers located in Old Saybrook?
It is located at 1657 Boston Post Road, Old Saybrook, CT 06475.
Is there an app available to order from Wayback Burgers?
Yes, you can download the Wayback Burgers app to order easily.
Are there any other dining options near Wayback Burgers?
Nearby dining options include Dunkin' for coffee and donuts, Baskin-Robbins for ice cream, and Cuckoo's Nest for Mexican cuisine.
Where can I get coffee near Wayback Burgers?
You can visit Dunkin', located nearby, for coffee, donuts, and smoothies.
Are there any nearby places for healthcare services?
Yes, Middlesex Health Urgent Care and Hartford HealthCare-GoHealth Urgent Care are close by for medical needs.
What attractions or stores can I visit near Wayback Burgers?
You can check out West Marine for boating supplies, Pet Valu for pet needs, and local restaurants like Alforno Trattoria Bar Pizza and ZENSHI Handcrafted Sushi.