Island Spice Restaurant
4.1226 reviews
Certified by Island Spice Restaurant • Feb 08, 2026
Business Details
459 Winthrop Ave., New Haven, CT
06511, United States
Certified by Island Spice Restaurant • Feb 08, 2026
(203) 290-1266
Certified by Island Spice Restaurant • Feb 08, 2026
https://www.islandspicect.com/
Certified by Island Spice Restaurant • Feb 08, 2026
About
Certified by Island Spice Restaurant • Feb 08, 2026
Jamaican RestaurantCaribbean Restaurant
Island Spice Restaurant provides authentic Jamaican cuisine in New Haven, CT.
Location
Certified by Island Spice Restaurant • Feb 08, 2026
Hours
Certified by Island Spice Restaurant • Feb 08, 2026
Reviews
4.1
226 reviews
5 stars
128
4 stars
44
3 stars
16
2 stars
14
1 star
24
What are people saying?
AI-generated from recent customer reviews
Food Quality
Many customers praised the food for being delicious and well-seasoned, particularly the jerk chicken and oxtails, though some noted inconsistencies in freshness and flavor.
Customer Service
Customer service received mixed reviews, with several complaints about rudeness, slow service, and order inaccuracies, while some customers appreciated friendly staff.
Pricing
Customers generally found the prices reasonable for the portion sizes, although some felt the food was overpriced for the quality received.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was criticized for being uninviting, with reports of people loitering outside and a lack of organization inside.
- RMRosalyn Moody4 days ago5.0Given Thx for Natalie! I'm Up 5a or So for Medical Reasons.11a Starts My Lunch Craving. My Plate of Cabbage and Cod, Pumpkin and Plantain etc was Just PERFECT! Of Course I'll be Nibbeling All Day and I'll Enjoy It ! Blessings to All 🙏
- CRCCT RepairsJan 7, 20265.0Island Spice never disappoints, pricing love it, proportions are generous, food always tastes fresh, jerk chicken never dry or to spicy, steamed cabbage is delicious and seasoned, and curry chicken flavored just right. Give them a try and say Hi to Miss Nelson. On Fridays they make Oven baked Mac and cheese by noon get your order in early I hear it goes fast, that’s the next thing on my list to try.
- SSSaniqueJan 5, 20265.0I had an amazing meal here! I ordered the liver and fried dumplings, and everything was cooked perfectly so flavorful and 'nice.' The prices are very reasonable for the quality of food you get. I’ll definitely be coming back for more!
- NCN CHOUDec 22, 20254.0Curry goat is really tasty, the portion is reasonable
- AJAnajah JacksonOct 10, 20251.0DONT EAT HERE! AS SOON AS I ATE MY OXTAIL (SUPPOSEDLY), RICE AND PEAS AND CABBAGE I HAD IMMEDIATE DIARRHEA AND THREW UP THE ENTIRE MEAL $30 DOWN THE DRAIN! THIS IS NOT OK!
Frequently Asked Questions About Island Spice Restaurant
What type of cuisine does Island Spice Restaurant specialize in?
Island Spice Restaurant specializes in authentic Jamaican cuisine in New Haven, CT.
What are the operating hours of Island Spice Restaurant?
The restaurant is open Monday through Friday from 6:30 AM to 8:00 PM, and on Sunday from 7:00 AM to 6:00 PM. It is closed on Saturdays.
Where is Island Spice Restaurant located?
It is located at 459 Winthrop Ave., New Haven, CT 06511, United States.
What payment options are accepted at Island Spice Restaurant?
Island Spice Restaurant accepts American Express, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, Mastercard, and Visa.
Does Island Spice Restaurant offer catering services?
Yes, they provide catering for corporate lunches, small office parties, family reunions, and also offer delivery.
How can customers contact Island Spice Restaurant?
Customers can call the main phone number at +1 203-290-1266 or the alternate phone at +1 203-785-0908. They can also email at ntracey21@comcast.net.
Is Island Spice Restaurant owned by a Black woman?
Yes, Island Spice Restaurant is both Black-owned and women-owned.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at Island Spice Restaurant?
You can visit nearby places like Levels Hair Salon for beauty services, The Gusto Kitchen for Mediterranean cuisine, or Dunkin Donuts for coffee and bakery items.
Are there any nearby restaurants offering different cuisines near Island Spice Restaurant?
Yes, nearby restaurants include Ladle and Loaf offering Middle Eastern cuisine, Shang Hai and China House serving Chinese food, and Whalley Pizza for pizza and American dishes.
Is there convenient transit or other services near Island Spice Restaurant that customers might find useful?
Yes, nearby services include Sylvan Cleaners for dry cleaning and laundromat services, as well as Jackson Hewitt Tax Service for financial advising, which might be helpful when visiting the area.
Brand Certified Facts from Island Spice Restaurant
Island Spice Restaurant partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified February 08, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website