Many customers praised the pizza, calzones, and garlic knots, highlighting their deliciousness and quality ingredients, while some expressed disappointment with undercooked or poorly topped pizzas.
Service Experience
The staff received mixed reviews; while many customers appreciated the friendly and attentive service, others reported issues with professionalism and responsiveness.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as cozy and inviting, with a nostalgic charm that makes it feel like a local favorite.
Pricing Concerns
Several customers mentioned that the prices are on the higher side, with some feeling that the value did not match the cost.
NA
Nick Ayde
5 days ago
5.0
Pizza is AMAZING! Born and raised in Arvada, and after 38 years I finally found this place — so glad we did. The staff is super friendly and the atmosphere is calm and family-oriented. Would recommend to anyone looking for a great experience. 10/10. 🍕
AR
Anthony Ramirez
Feb 20, 2026
1.0
If you not white they will not survive you well or treat you like a prison I’m Mexican American and my friend is black came in to eat they let us sit down and that was it they didn’t even came get our order but a Group of white people came in after us They were nice friendly attentive and placed their order but we sat there and wasted our lunch break here. I will not be coming back here and I do not recommend anybody coming here that is not white because they’re not gonna treat you the same and they make it known by the way they look at you and just forget about you. I wouldn’t know what the food tasted like didn’t even get to place my order and it seemed like they didn’t even care
So that make it right too Treat us like we are nothing Group of white men come in after us and got there food with in 5 minutes and we got water and forgotten about ya that makes sense
CD
Connor Daniels
Feb 18, 2026
1.0
Do not order door dash from here, they have no respect for their drivers.
Let's get one thing clear, criticism is NOT a personal attack, if I bring up a consistant issue that I have with your restaurant that is NOT yelling at you, it is NOT me attacking you, it is me as a contractor of your business trying to remedy an issue I am having that is affecting my business. So when your waitress responds to my professional criticism with rudeness, hysterics, screaming and refusal to uphold your end of our contract, it speaks to the contempt you have for the arrangement you have with your contractors, it is the height of unprofessionalism and worst of all it decreases that quality of the experience of your online customer.
I have been working as a door dasher for several years while I build by own business, and since I’m sure the owner of this establishment is going to read this review, I hope you do so as one businessperson to another knowing that I do understand it’s not easy to run a business, much less a restaurant much less for as long as you and I assume your family have. Now, I’ve done nearly 7000 orders for door dash orders for hundreds of restaurants and NEVER have I been treated so rudely, or spoken to with such contempt as I was this evening by your employee.
Bottom line, this business does not care about it’s online customers, my in personal experience their food is also severely overpriced soggy garbage, and actively hostile to their contracted partners. I cannot recommend patronizing this business, but I will happily sing the praises from the rooftops for Benny Blancos! they are located just up the street at 10050 Ralston Rd, they serve pizza by the slice that does not look like a hot piece of burnt rubber (honestly look at the sad excuse for a pizza in that disgusting oven by the bar at little nick’s) They also have free delivery to anyone in a 2 mile radius and have some of the most amazing New York style pizza I’ve ever had in Colorado, they used to be in Denver but now their right here in arvada and they don’t treat their delivery drivers like ——-.
SM
Savannah Mahoney
Feb 16, 2026
1.0
Although the pizza was decent we cannot support the AI slop all over their media
The AI pictures of the food is incredibly disappointing
JH
Joey Hall-Palmer
Feb 16, 2026
5.0
Party of 6 from Australia and Scotland landed at Nicks after flying in from around the globe. Although later in a Sunday, we were met by Shar (fabulous hostess) with grace, humour and friendlyness. Pizzas wete fantastic and Bobs Cobb salad just what this weary traveller needed (3am UK time not my usual dinner slot!) Both were loaded and delicious. Good music, locals with recommendations and banter - a great start to our EPIC trip. Shar - thanks for being wonderful and would recommend this to all who are in the area - fab spot.