Li'l Nick's Pizza

Reviews

• AC

  Alfred Coca

  Nov 17, 2025
  1.0
  Terrible pizza under cooked toppings were cold
• NF

  Noah F

  Nov 1, 2025
  2.0
  Very unsatisfied with the food we had ordered last weekend. I figured being a pizza joint that has been around a long time that the quality of the food would match the scene set for me. Boy was I wrong. The dough for the pizza had a serious lack of flavor and was partially burned in spots. The biggest upset for my girlfriend and I were the toppings. Yes...we got what we asked for...but the fact I was charged $3 per topping and they weren't consistently spread throughout the pizza and mostly were concentrated around the center of the pizza had me at such a loss. So I went and looked at pictures of other people who had attended this restaurant for a similar product and what we received was nothing like what they had. They had toppings all throughout the pizza and fairly loaded up as well. Very disappointed that I am the odd one out and get dogged on by being overcharged for a lack of flavor, lack of toppings, and overall shitty pizza buying experience. Sure the restaurant was cute and old timey and the service was mediocre at best, but at the end of the day if Im paying $30 for a single large pizza, I'd expect the quality and consistency of product to be there and it wasn't. Seriously and Im not kidding...we both looked at one another after first slice and both said "We should've just went to Lil Ceasars or Dominoes". Im not one to complain, but if you are gonna take my money like that at least live up to the hype that is posted on Google by previous customers and dont just scam me out of $30 for a mid tiered pizza. I would like to give Lil Nick's a redo but not for the price and quality they are producing. Not worth your time or money in my opinion.
• JS

  John Sargeant

  Oct 31, 2025
  5.0
  Carry out this time, but have enjoyed the “local, family owned & operated vibes during previous visits.
• JS

  Jeff Sanchez

  Oct 28, 2025
  5.0
  My girlfriend and I love this little pizza spot. Quality ingredients make the best food.
• BW

  Bat Woman

  Oct 24, 2025
  5.0
  I stumbled upon this gem when I first moved to Colorado. I happened to move into the apts right behind it. And OMG!!!! The meatball sliders......let me just say, since moving back to Utah, I've made a few trips back to Colorado just because I was craving them! I've paid friends and family that I knew were passing through to stop and bring me back some of those sliders!

Frequently Asked Questions About Li'l Nick's Pizza