Numerous customers reported extremely slow service, with long wait times for seating, drinks, and food, often despite the restaurant being not busy.
Order Accuracy
Many reviews highlighted consistent problems with order accuracy, including missing items and incorrect food preparation.
Management Concerns
Several customers expressed dissatisfaction with management, citing poor oversight and lack of responsiveness to service issues.
Food Quality
Feedback indicated that food quality was inconsistent, with reports of cold, undercooked, or poorly prepared items.
Positive Staff Experiences
Despite the negative feedback, some customers praised individual staff members for their excellent service and attentiveness.
CL
Crepe Lynn
3 days ago
5.0
Usually this place is buns, but Sarah and Christina redeemed this place 🙏
SN
Salmita Y Nataya
Jan 2, 2026
1.0
El peor servicio que he recibido. !!! En el lugar solo se apreciaba dos clientes, yo tenia aproximadamente 20 min esperando en recepción, pregunte a una chica que pasaba !!! Me dijo que esperara 10 min mas porque solo habia un mesero !!! Que locura !!! En viernes!! Aun asi no habia clientes, alcance a ver a unos 6 empleados .. no podían con tres clientes o no querían??? Adjunto fotos del lugar casi solo ..
BK
Brian Kelsey
Dec 21, 2025
1.0
They will consistently mess your order up. In restaurant or pickup, they will forget something. Service is slow and terrible when you do get it.
M1
Mr 123
Dec 17, 2025
1.0
I went to this place on 12/14/25 at 9pm. I had my two kids along with a relative and her daughter. When we walked in, there was no host at the stand. We waited for about a minute. As I looked around it didn’t seem that busy. Most of football was over but there was basketball and other games on their tv’s. Since no one acknowledged us to include the servers who were running either drinks or food or were cleaning tables didn’t acknowledge us. There was a bunch of open seating in the bar area so I figured we would take a seat at one of the high tables. The female bartender displayed an idiot don’t care mentality and never wanted to come over. Now I get we all have busy days but in this industry you have to fake it to make it. She just cleaned her area and paced back and forth. We made eye contact a few times but she never came over. I checked the time and they don’t close until 11pm on a Sunday. Due to no one communicating / acknowledging us, we left and went somewhere else. No wonder this place is a 3.3. Thankfully I don’t live in this area and only travel, because I would never go back to this place. I’d rather go to Perrys’s Nextdoor.
DG
Delainie Gonsoir
Dec 6, 2025
3.0
This is the WORST location ever. I didn’t have a drink for 35 minutes, and when I got one it was not what I ordered at all. Brought me another that was the same. Ordered a Mountain Dew that was clear and no taste, brought 2 over that were not it at all. Waited another 15 minutes for a beer. Multiple clarifications with the waitress, who had absolutely no idea what she was doing, nor did seem like anyone else on the floor. They were not busy at all and the “kitchen was really backed up”. 45 minutes for food (10 wings and a cheeseburger). The food was COLD. Table of 6 next to us and another two couples had no food or drinks for almost the same amount of time as us. I remember coming here a couple years ago and it was just as bad. Spoke to the manager and he made things right but overall I am just not sure I’ll be back here.
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What is the address of Buffalo Wild Wings in Sheridan, CO?
Buffalo Wild Wings is located at 3900 River Point Parkway, Sheridan, CO 80110, USA.
What are the operating hours of Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Sheridan is open from 11:00 AM to 12:00 AM Monday through Saturday, and from 10:30 AM to 11:00 PM on Sundays.
What kind of food does Buffalo Wild Wings in Sheridan serve?
The restaurant serves award-winning Buffalo, New York-style wings with a choice of 26 sauces and seasonings.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan currently open?
Buffalo Wild Wings in Sheridan is currently open and not closed.
What phone number can I use to contact Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan?
You can contact Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan at +1 303-789-9280.
Where can I find more information or visit online about Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan?
More information is available at https://www.buffalowildwings.com/locations/us/co/sheridan/3900-river-point-pkwy/sports-bar-1413/
Are there other dining options near Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan?
Yes, nearby restaurants include Old Chicago (pizza), Parry's Pizzeria and Taphouse (pizza and beer), Reel Cajun Seafood Restaurant, Chili's Grill & Bar (American and Mexican cuisines), Teriyaki Madness (Asian fusion), and It's Just Wings (chicken wings delivery).
What entertainment or shopping venues are close to Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan?
Nearby you can find Performance Wheel & Tire (arcade and retail), Sportsman's Warehouse (outdoor gear), Conn's HomePlus (electronics and appliances), Burlington (clothing and department store), and PetSmart (pet supplies).
How can nearby services benefit customers visiting Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan?
Customers visiting Buffalo Wild Wings can conveniently access services at nearby locations like America's Best Contacts & Eyeglasses for eyewear, Xfinity for internet services, and T-Mobile for mobile needs, enhancing their overall visit to the area.
What categories does Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan fall under?
Buffalo Wild Wings Sheridan is categorized as a Chicken Wings Restaurant, Sports Bar, Restaurant, and Takeout Restaurant.