RARE is an Italian steakhouse located in the heart of Old Town in Fort Collins, Colorado. Inspired by travel experiences in central Italy, RARE offers a rustic, farm-to-table approach to dishes often found in Umbria and Tuscany. RARE’s menus feature fresh, homemade pasta and cheeses, the best in-house dry-aged steaks in Northern Colorado, and an extensive list of New and Old World wines.
This had the most impeccable food I've tasted. The best tiramisu I've ever had anywhere, and I've had a good deal of it, literally melts in your mouth. It was unbelievable, and Josiah was great for taking care of me the very first time!
KW
Kerri Webb
2 days ago
4.0
Atmosphere: lovely, some group/social dining, very comfortable.
Cocktails: nice, expected, enjoyable.
Service: attentive, polite, friendly, often was almost too quick to bring food, felt slightly rushed on occasion.
Food: appetizers: meatballs, very tender and tasty. Arancini: were good, but strongly flavored. My husband loved them, I did not. Mains: I got the ravioli, perfectly done pasta, but very salty. Overly so in my opinion. Hubbie got the Bolognese, it was delicious, again pasta perfectly cooked. Dessert: got the tirramisu. large portion! But 😒 Very creamy (too much filling) next to NO coffee flavor at all. Actually ordered a shot of espresso and dumped it on top. Made it better. Otherwise, it was like a mild cheesecake, not tirramisu.
Will try again, but with reservations.
JM
Jenelle Marshall
Apr 20, 2026
5.0
My husband and I went here for a date yesterday and the whole experience was exceptional. Jocelyn was our server and she was FANTASTIC! I let her know that I was lactose intolerant and she made sure nothing had dairy in it. One of the best servers we have come accross ever! Food was incredible as well. We took home our leftovers and delicious dessert that Jocelyn reccomended. We will be visiting again.
JK
Joseph Kim
Apr 16, 2026
5.0
Great service from our waitress Katie. The food was really good! Only gave a 4 star on the food due to steak needing a bit more seasoning when it was served. The carbonara was on point, the bruschetta was also delicious.
MA
Michael Patterson (Adventures4ME)
Apr 10, 2026
5.0
We had a wonderful experience the other afternoon here at RARE Italian and felt it was important to share. We popped in just after they opened with a party of 3, but with no reservation. We were welcomed by the hostess, despite not having a reservation, and quickly seated at a wonderful booth.
It was Happy Hour, and we all decided to try to order from the happy hour menu to ample everything. Our waitress, Savanna, was so pleasant and willing to answer our questions and offer suggestions. While we did order from the happy our menu, we did make it a full meal, with dessert and digestif.
In short, the cocktails, wine, mussels, calamari, meatballs, salad, and dessert were all FANTASTIC!
We have dined before for a full meal, and their selection of dry aged meats and pastas are out of this world!!!
You must join them for a meal if you are in the area. I promise, you will thank me :)
What type of cuisine does RARE Italian specialize in?
RARE Italian is an Italian steakhouse offering Rustic, farm-to-table dishes inspired by central Italy, particularly Umbria and Tuscany.
Where is RARE Italian located?
RARE Italian is located at 101 S. College Avenue, Fort Collins, CO 80524 in the Old Town Fort Collins neighborhood.
What are the opening hours of RARE Italian?
RARE Italian is open daily from 4:00 PM to 9:15 PM.
Does RARE Italian offer pickup or delivery services?
RARE Italian offers in-store pickup and also provides delivery services with no-contact delivery available.
Can I make a reservation at RARE Italian?
Yes, RARE Italian accepts reservations but does not require them.
What payment options does RARE Italian accept?
They accept American Express, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, Visa, debit and credit cards.
Is RARE Italian wheelchair accessible?
Yes, RARE Italian has wheelchair accessible entrances, parking, seating, and restrooms.
What can I expect on the menu at RARE Italian?
The menu features fresh homemade pasta and cheeses, house dry-aged steaks, antipasti, wine, cocktails, and happy hour offerings, including vegetarian and vegan options.
What nearby places can I visit before or after dining at RARE Italian?
Nearby you can visit The Mainline Ale House, a popular pub and bar; Walrus Ice Cream for desserts; and Pendleton, a clothing store, perfect for shopping.
How can I use nearby transportation or attractions to find RARE Italian?
RARE Italian is centrally located in Old Town Fort Collins near popular spots like Starry Night Espresso Cafe and FirstBank, making it easily accessible for visitors exploring local shops and cafes.
Brand Certified Facts from RARE Italian
This information is certified by RARE Italian and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified April 26, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: