Catch Steak

Reviews

• WP

  W PCS

  4 days ago
  4.0
  We were a party of 6 and had a good experience. Our server was a bit lost with our table during service. He wasn't around much and came to offer dessert before we hadn't even had out mains yet. Only then he went to kitchen to check and had our mains delivered. At the end he also said the desserts were small, so to order 2 for sharing but the chocolate cake was enormous. Food was great overall. I had the 10oz Chili Rubbed Grass Fed NY Strip and was amazing. Everything was delicious. Great atmosphere but a little bit loud. I appreciated very much that the restaurant did not add automatically the TIP to the bill and let the customers decide. This makes me want to come back. Overall, we had a good experience and will want to come back.
• KA

  Kyle Asman

  Feb 28, 2026
  5.0
  John the GM is awesome, Fantastic Wine List, Great Service, and always awesome food. Great vibe by the bar as well.
• CN

  Charlotte Nicholson

  Feb 24, 2026
  5.0
  It was my first time to Catch and while I heard a lot about it from around town, I wanted to see if the service was worth the high price point. I was wowed by the atmosphere and staff from the moment I stepped in the building. Thea was welcoming with a smile and very friendly at the coat check. Alejandro was attentive and engaging in conversation as we sat down at our table. He told us about living in Peru and it was amazing to talk to him and we shared a laugh about having two Alejandro’s in our party as well. He kept checking in on us and made our night special. Catch exceeded expectations and while the sushi was outstanding we will be back for the incredible staff!
• MA

  Malik Ajala

  Feb 15, 2026
  5.0
  Best drinks in town made by Johnathan! Sushi and hamachi were delicious, can’t wait to come back and try other menu items
• JH

  Jon H.

  Feb 11, 2026
  5.0
  Great group dinner for 8 just like last year. We sat upstairs and tend to go a little early which I think is a pro tip to get the best service and seats. The appetizers and cocktails steal the show. The steaks are quite good and better than most in the Aspen area if not all, but certainly don't elevate themselves over great steak houses in NY, LA, Miami, Vegas, etc. so come for a steak but really stay for everything else. For steaks we had the 40oz tomahawk and the 24 oz wagyu porterhouse. The wagyu was exceptional - tend, perfectly cooked, etc. but the tomahawk was overly charred on all edges (it's hard to cook those, I understand). Spicy tuna and catch rolls were great - they oddly do a nice job with sushi here - it's not as good as Matsuhisa but nice to add to mains or an app. Apps: - always order the Wedge Salad! I don't like blue cheese and get it on the side but their sesame dressing is a 10/10 - unique, amazing. - Caesar - lots of dressing but basically delicious - so good. - pretzel bread - can't go wrong with this of course... - simple green beans are recommended along with a "sharing" truffle tagliolini if you road hard that day. We had all this and it was less by about 40% than eating at Yuki the next night - smoked old fashioned rounds, a nice bottle of red, and some other craft drinks finished off a great experience. Really consistent 3 years in a row for me - has earned 5 stars. Keep it up!

Frequently Asked Questions About Catch Steak