Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• KW

  Kimberley West

  Feb 19, 2026
  5.0
  Tasty pizzas and the staff is so friendly and helpful.
• HS

  Heidi Stolte

  Feb 12, 2026
  1.0
  Order pizzas, it took two and a half hours to arrive. I called the store they stated they got overwhelmed with orders and misplaced mine. The store didn't even offer any type of compensation for their mistakes and for making us wait two and a half hours. When we opened the pizzas they looked like crap, very messy and one pizza barely had any cheese on it. Plus I asked for them to be square cut and they weren't. Lordy, it only got worse when we tried the pizzas, complete salt bombs! Toppings salty, cheese salty and crusts salty. The pizzas were inedible, we ended up throwing them in the trash. There went $54 literally in the trash. I will never order from them again, if I could give them zero stars, I would. Horrible experience, would not recommend. You'd be better off ordering Pizza Hut.
• TT

  Tee

  Feb 6, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered a gluten-free pizza and let them know I had an allergy. But it still got crossed contaminated, and as a result, I got sick when I completed the survey for my order the manager called me and told me that it was my fault. “I'm trying to figure out exactly what happened with the order because usually my employees are pretty good at, um, doing things correctly. I haven't had an issue with this before. Um, so I was just, uh, calling me to see if I can get more information and then try to make the situation” I tried this place and didn’t get sick. So I tried it again and got sick. It’s not my fault. I trusted the company. But as a result of the employees incompetence of allergies I cannot return.
• RS

  Robert Stane

  Feb 1, 2026
  1.0
  I ordered the pizza for a 4:15 pm pick up. It was made early and lukewarm. Instead of the crust being crispy, it was like a dish sponge. I was surprised at the lack of quality. It was more like a $7 DiSorno frozen pizza. Will not buy again...
• CC

  Chelsea C

  Jan 24, 2026
  1.0
  45 minutes for a pizza during lunch is insane. Only ONE employee running the entire store? That’s not a staffing issue—that’s straight-up mismanagement. The worker is honestly doing an amazing job holding everything together alone and clearly deserves a raise, but let’s be real: if the owner can’t even schedule one extra person, I highly doubt that’ll happen. The whole place feels depressing, and you can literally feel the stress in the air. It’s uncomfortable as a customer and unfair to the employee. I don’t think businesses like this should be supported—there’s zero empathy for their workers and zero respect for customers. Waiting 45 minutes for a pizza because management is cheap and incompetent is completely unacceptable.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza