NY Pie

Reviews

• CR

  Christina Runyan

  Nov 14, 2025
  5.0
  Quality people working here! Great service!
• RW

  Randi Wiley

  Nov 6, 2025
  5.0
  First time here, I was out of town visitor to California. Pizza was really good. Loved the crust and sauce. The cinnamon knots for dessert were to die for. So many yummy local beers on tap and in bottles. Service was top notch too, friendly and quick staff. Spoke with the new owner, he recently bought this location and renovated it, changed up the menu and crust recipe. One of the only places open late in Santa Rosa as well. I will be back!
• GC

  Gregory Chu

  Nov 2, 2025
  5.0
  Excellent pizza if you like NY thin crust. I always try a plain cheese pizza first to gauge if I will like their pizza before trying the other options. This place did not disappoint. It was even great lukewarm (I ordered delivery and it was barely warm when I got it). I'll be back to try the hot wings and some other options next time I'm in town!
• MA

  Michelle Adams

  Oct 30, 2025
  5.0
  My husband and I went to NY Pizza a couple of weeks ago. It has been on our '"go to" for several months. 1) Love the atmosphere. It changes with the time of day and which day. On sports evenings, it can be loud but not objectionably loud. More of a friends getting together to watch a game noise. We can still hear each other without difficulty. It's a fun vibe. 2) The food. The pizza is always hot when it gets to our table. My husband prefers a regular crust or thick crust but....he really likes the pizza and the crust here. It''s not crunchy or as a little blackened as some other thin crust places have. The toppings are excellent. I always get a salad. I'm picky about my salads. I don't like arugula, not a fan of iceberg or mixed greens. Love romaine, crunchy and mild flavor. They always accommodate me. In other words, I make my own. They have a homemade lemon dressing that is excellent. I bought some from them, only in little 30cc cups...I bought 10. I'm hoping they will bottle some. Never have I had such a fresh lemon dressing like this. 3) Service. I can't say enough. They greet you when you come in, they get your food ready and delivered. Yes, they warm up your slice but it doesn't taste warmed over. The staff is always smiling and ready to meet your needs for more of everything or if you need something else. They check on you without being "in your space." The owner.....awesome. Very friendly and genuinely wants to hear about your experience. Love NY Pie!
• RZ

  Richard Zimmer

  Oct 26, 2025
  5.0
  WE are a couple raised in NYC. You have made the best edge crust and undercrust we hve experiencing ij CA; closest to the NYC pizza crust here. However, the sauce could be more tangy and the cheese is supposed to be stretchy. NYC pizza cheese can be stretched across the entire box. In the future, we will only buy your pizza. Bravo!

Frequently Asked Questions About NY Pie