NY Pie

Reviews

• AR

  Amit Ram

  Feb 24, 2026
  5.0
  I heard i should try the new and improved pizza recipe and it did not disappoint. The neopolitan tasted fresh and hit the spot. They also have a great craft beer selection!
• VS

  V S

  Feb 22, 2026
  5.0
  Pizza is fabulous. Grand Central Station is sooooo good. I’m from New England where the pizza is so much better than west coast. These guys know how to make pizza!!!
• HA

  Hector Amador

  Feb 21, 2026
  1.0
  Disappointing lack of hospitality – Turned away 30 minutes before closing My family and I have been long-time patrons of NY Pie, but our experience this past Friday night was unacceptable. We took an Uber from Sonoma specifically for your pizza, arriving at 11:30 PM—a full 30 minutes before the midnight closing time. Despite being well within operating hours, we were turned away. The staff explicitly stated they would not take our order because the kitchen was already cleaned and they did not want to re-clean it. It was clear the team prioritized an early departure over serving customers. We were forced to order a return Uber and leave empty-handed. Ownership should be aware that revenue is being turned away by a staff that lacks basic hospitality and a commitment to posted hours. This experience left a very bad taste in my family's mouth.
• AH

  Andy Hilliard

  Feb 6, 2026
  5.0
  This place is a weekly ritual. A pilgrimage. A Friday night religion. NY Pie doesn’t pretend to be New York pizza…..it is New York pizza. The kind that bends without breaking. The kind with a crust that’s chewy, substantial, confident. No limp nonsense. No wine-country “interpretation.” Just authentic, old-school, no-apologies flavor that hits you right in the soul. And the beer list? Absurd in the best way. A rotating parade of West Coast IPAs that could make a hop head weep. Bonus points (huge ones) for pouring every glass right to the brink like they respect both beer and humanity. That matters. Now let’s talk wings…..because skipping them would be a personal failure. They don’t beg for attention. They don’t posture. They just quietly sit there being possibly the greatest wings ever to exist. Ignore them at your own peril and lifelong regret. Shout-out to Sandra, our server. Newbie or not, she’s the living embodiment of the place’s culture—friendly, sharp, genuinely happy to be there. The kind of service that makes you relax your shoulders and order one more round. The atmosphere feels like the five boroughs somehow snuck into……Sonoma County wine country. You walk in expecting pinot noir and charcuterie and instead you get attitude, energy, and damn good pizza. We come here nearly every Friday. That should tell you everything. If you love pizza and you have a pulse, this place delivers. Boom.
• KM

  Kat Montgomery

  Jan 30, 2026
  4.0
  The only reason they don't get perfect ratings is that they do not have a way to customize pizza on their website. i called in to place the order and was told i MUST order on line for deliveries. I told that person their was no "customize" button online. He got on line as well and agreed there wasn't and spent about 10 minutes trying to help. Finally he said to place an order and when it came up in the que, he would tell the cooks what i really wanted. i've been in the restaurant business and didn't see how this would work but agreed as i had always liked their pizzas in the past before the changes. sure enough, it didn't work and i got a call from someone about 30 minutes before delivery date. i had called back and was told the order could not be seen until 30 minutes before delivery. sure enough, the new caller at least knew this was not the pizza of choice and i then told him what was wanted. it arrived on time and was very good, slightly soft in the middle, probably from rushing but the person who returned my call was great and so was most of the pizza, so if they get a customized button online, i may reorder.

Frequently Asked Questions About NY Pie