Customers frequently reported slow and inattentive service, with many experiencing long waits for food and drinks, and some noting rude or unhelpful staff.
Food Quality
While some customers enjoyed the wings, many others complained about cold or poorly prepared food, including issues with incorrect orders and unsatisfactory presentation.
Management Concerns
Several reviews highlighted poor management practices, including lack of responsiveness to customer complaints and inadequate staffing during busy times.
Positive Staff Experiences
Despite the overall negative feedback, some customers praised individual staff members for their friendliness and attentiveness, indicating potential for better service.
Atmosphere and Cleanliness
The atmosphere was generally appreciated for sports viewing, but cleanliness issues, particularly in restrooms, were noted as a concern.
KB
kara bondietti
Nov 17, 2025
3.0
The food was ok nothing like what I have had at other places. The server was great. The seating staff was ok
KK
Katelyn
Nov 3, 2025
1.0
Went over the weekend here with my boyfriend for some lunch and our waitress Cici was just not it. She didn’t bring us any napkins or silverware at all, she definitely saw us struggling to grab our drinks cause of dirty hands yet she still provided her other tables behind us with napkins and silverware. We also accidentally spilt a drink and she saw us trying to clean it up and still didn’t offer any napkins or towels for us, same goes for this guy walking around in front of us cleaning already cleaned tables seeing we needed help. Our bill ended up being $51.62 I still tipped $5 despite our waitress being not the best so my total should’ve been $56.62 coming out of my bank and instead I was charged $61.62, double the tip I originally put for her.
AH
Adam Hughes
Oct 30, 2025
3.0
I really want this place to be good. We keep coming back because we like wings, the setup, and the overall concept. Having both worked in service, we know what it takes to run a good business, and that’s probably why this is so frustrating.
If you can sit at the bar, you’ll usually have a great experience. The bar staff consistently hustles, keeps things friendly, and handles way more than they should. But when you’re seated elsewhere, it’s a completely different story.
The managers move at the pace of sloths. The issue isn’t just that things are slow. It’s that they’re visible, standing around while tables sit unbussed, food gets cold, and guests wait. The restaurant is rarely full, yet somehow there’s always a wait, even when it’s maybe 40% capacity. If it were just a short-staffing issue, I’d understand. But when you see multiple managers not stepping in and several employees on their phones, it’s clear the culture is off.
We hung in there because we were hungry and wanted to watch the game, but we probably should have left. We ordered an appetizer right away and watched as every table around us got food before we did. When we finally asked, the server checked with the manager and brought out cold fried pickles. The wings were good, but you could tell they had been sitting under a heat lamp.
I want this location to succeed. There’s potential here, and I think a lot of people want to support it too. But if things keep going the way they are, I can see why most guests might not come back after the first visit. We’ll keep trying, at least for now.
DS
Daniel S
Oct 23, 2025
1.0
This is the first review I’ve ever done. But Buffalo Wild Wings in SM is so bad I had to. The food is fine…when it’s not served cold. But the service is so historically bad it’s a running joke among everyone I know. It’s not a recent issue. It’s been this bad since it opened. I’ve never once had a good dining experience there. I wait a few months before trying again hoping for something different but it never is. The last time I went I took someone who had never been. Not for the food, but for entertainment. I told the person I went with how horrible the service was beforehand and how in the 10 times I’ve been there not one time was it decent. Buffalo Wild Wings did not disappoint. The food wasn’t worth it…but the laughs my friend and I had with every thing wrong with the experience was. LOL. I won’t get too much into the details about all of things consistently wrong with this place. But here’s the short version. Long waits for food even if the place is empty, cold food, wrong food, charged for food I didn’t order, hair in food, staff never returns after food is brought. You name it…I’ve experienced it. Anywhere from one of those to a few of those have happened. Every….single….time. It’s not bad. It’s the worst. Hands down. By the way…if you do go…save yourself the cost of buying drinks. Their tea and soda are so watered down they taste like water anyways. Geez. There you go Buffalo. You’re so bad you made someone who doesn’t do reviews do their first. LOL.
HH
Harman
Oct 21, 2025
5.0
ofcourse it was crazy busy because i visited on a sunday
Staff was still veey patient and friendly, smiling, welcoming
Frequently Asked Questions About Buffalo Wild Wings
What type of food is served at Buffalo Wild Wings in Santa Maria?
Buffalo Wild Wings serves award-winning Buffalo-style chicken wings in 26 different sauces and seasonings.
Where is the Buffalo Wild Wings location in Santa Maria?
It is located at 795 East Betteravia Road, Santa Maria, CA 93454.
What are the opening hours of Buffalo Wild Wings on weekdays?
From Monday to Wednesday, the restaurant is open from 11:00 AM to 12:00 AM, and on Thursday and Friday, it is open from 11:00 AM to 2:00 AM.
Is Buffalo Wild Wings open on Sundays, and what are the hours?
Yes, it is open on Sundays from 9:30 AM to 12:00 AM.
How can I contact Buffalo Wild Wings in Santa Maria?
You can call them at +1 805-354-0464 for inquiries or reservations.
Does Buffalo Wild Wings offer takeout services?
Yes, among its categories, Buffalo Wild Wings is listed as a takeout restaurant.
Which nearby restaurants can I visit around Buffalo Wild Wings in Santa Maria?
Nearby restaurants include Cracker Barrel Old Country Store, Jack In The Box, Popeyes Louisiana Kitchen, Blaze Pizza, and Urbane Cafe, offering a variety of options from breakfast and brunch to fast food and pizza.
Are there any nearby automotive services close to Buffalo Wild Wings?
Yes, Toyota Of Santa Maria (brake service and used car dealer), Conserv Fuel gas station, and Scion Of Santa Maria car dealer are nearby if you need automotive services.
What shopping options are available near Buffalo Wild Wings in Santa Maria?
You can find stores such as HomeGoods, Ashley Furniture HomeStore, Old Navy, DICK'S Sporting Goods, and Kirkland's nearby for home goods, clothing, and sporting goods shopping.
Are there any beauty and spa services near Buffalo Wild Wings?
Yes, nearby beauty and spa locations include Benefit Cosmetics BrowBar, Ulta Beauty, Charlotte Tilbury, The Nail Lounge Santa Maria, and CosmoProf.