Customers have mixed feelings about the pizza, with many praising the deep dish while others criticize the thin crust and sauce-to-dough ratio.
Service Speed
Service is often noted as slow, especially during busy times, leading to longer wait times for food.
Atmosphere
The restaurant has a pleasant atmosphere with outdoor seating, but some reviews mention it can be loud inside.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers feel the prices are high for the quality and portion sizes, particularly for certain menu items.
Dietary Options
The restaurant is appreciated for offering gluten-free and vegan options, catering to various dietary needs.
EE
Ellie
Nov 15, 2025
5.0
Got a pizza for takeout. Although the price was high for a small (feeds more like one hungry person), the girl who answered the phone was SO sweet & the service was quick. Very tasty pizza— loved the original crust! I’d come back here for dine in as well. Parking is easy, and they did a great job with the atmosphere inside.
TO
Trixie O
Nov 9, 2025
5.0
Me and my husband love coming to The Shop Pizza and Cocktails whenever we’re in town. The food is always incredible and the service is top-notch. We usually see Jesse, who always takes great care of us, and this last time Cole was just as attentive.
I have food allergies, which makes dining out tough at a lot of places, but here they’re genuinely accommodating and go out of their way to make sure I’m safe and comfortable.
Love this place — 5 stars all the way!
DY
David Yu
Nov 3, 2025
1.0
I ordered through the "Too good to go" app twice from them. I thought I'd be receiving left over pizzas or whatnot... what i ended up taking home was round pile of dough that was not fully cooked with a thin layer of tomato sauce. I basically received the base kit for a DIY pizza... both times
Now... I understand I can't expect much since I did order from "Too good to go"... but it was clear the chef just shoved something in the oven just to give me something.
If the restaurant does not plan to have left overs for the end of the day... why participate with "Too good to go?" I came for left overs.... not half hearted uncooked pile of dough.
CD
Crystal Duerr
Nov 2, 2025
1.0
Ordered a large pepperoni deep dish pizza and was pretty disappointed. The total came out to over $31, which felt steep considering the “large” was closer to a small or medium at most other pizza places. The flavor was overwhelmingly saucy — almost like drinking pizza sauce. Honestly, the deep dish pizza from the frozen section at Costco tastes way better for a fraction of the price. Wouldn’t recommend this place if you’re looking for good deep dish.
DM
Dustin Moffat
Nov 2, 2025
1.0
Save your money, worst pizza I have had. They put so much sauce on the top. If you like thin bread and tomato paste, this is the pizza for you. I can’t believe some think this is good. Awful.