While many dishes were praised for their flavor and presentation, there were several complaints about overcooked or bland items, particularly steaks and seafood.
Service
Service received mixed reviews; while some servers were noted as attentive and friendly, others were criticized for being slow or inattentive.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's views and ambiance were frequently highlighted as exceptional, contributing positively to the overall dining experience.
Value
Several customers felt that the prices were high relative to the quality of food and service received, leading to mixed feelings about the overall value.
Special Occasions
The restaurant is often chosen for celebrations, with many guests appreciating the extra attention given to special events like anniversaries and birthdays.
TT
traceyse1
Nov 11, 2025
5.0
Wonderful meal with the family. We had a very good server in Jessie S. All the staff were great, but she really stood out
CK
ChRIS KANG
Nov 9, 2025
4.0
식전빵과 starter로 나온 문어요리가 맛있었음 메인으 시킨 양갈비와 dry aged New York steak는 굽기도 제대로 안나왔고 별로 여긴 seafood맛집인듯
CM
Charles Meriot
Oct 22, 2025
5.0
Great restaurant, service was fast and high quality. Restaurant was not too busy on a Sunday night at 8PM. We had an incredible view of the bay and city at night. Very romantic. Food was delicious and came in copious amounts. Enjoyed the Ahi & crab appetizer and triple meats dish. Server was very friendly and knowledgeable about the area.
BB
Brittany B
Oct 18, 2025
5.0
I’ve eaten at countless restaurants over my 31 years, but nothing and I mean nothing compares to the calamari here. It was hands-down the best calamari I’ve ever had in my life: perfectly crisp, tender, and seasoned to absolute perfection. If I could give it 100stars, I would!
The coconut shrimp was also out of this world lightly breaded, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. And the fish and chips (with hush puppies!) were equally fantastic. Every dish was clearly made with care, love, and skill.
If you’re looking for a place that knows how to do seafood right, this is it. I’ll be dreaming about that calamari until my next visit!
Shout out to Chef Deborah!!!
JB
Jeffrey Barnes
Oct 17, 2025
5.0
Let me start off by saying that SETH and company were absolutely amazing tonight! Seth was very attentive and explained the menu VERY well and very knowledgeable of everything in house! He made us feel welcomed and right at home! Every recommendation he made, it delivered! The cooks are amazing. My only complaint would have to be THINNER asparagus needed!! The food came out in a very timely manner! We will most definitely be visiting this location again
Yes, Island Prime accepts reservations, which can be made through their reservation website or OpenTable.
What are the operating hours of Island Prime?
Island Prime is open for dinner from 5:00 PM to 9:00 PM Monday through Friday and Sunday, and from 4:00 PM to 9:00 PM on Saturday.
What type of cuisine does Island Prime offer?
Island Prime offers American cuisine with fine dining and steakhouse specialties.
Is Island Prime suitable for families with children?
Island Prime has a children's menu and high chairs available but generally does not welcome families with children.
Does Island Prime serve alcoholic beverages?
Yes, Island Prime serves a full range of alcoholic beverages including wine, beer, cocktails, and liquor, and has a bar onsite.
Does Island Prime have outdoor seating and accessibility features?
Yes, Island Prime offers outdoor seating and is fully wheelchair accessible with accessible entrances, parking, seating, and restrooms.
What payment options are accepted at Island Prime?
Island Prime accepts major credit cards including American Express, Discover, Mastercard, Visa, as well as debit cards and mobile NFC payments.
What nearby attractions can I visit before or after dining at Island Prime?
You can visit nearby spots such as Coasterra and Skyline Bar at Coasterra for cocktails, or take boat tours with San Diego Catamarans or Sail Riviera San Diego to enjoy the bay area.
Is there a convenient way to enjoy nightlife near Island Prime?
Yes, you can visit lounges and bars nearby like C Level Lounge and Harbor Docs bar to continue your evening after dining at Island Prime.
How can I get to Island Prime using local amenities?
Island Prime is located on Harbor Island Drive with nearby boat tours and marinas such as Safe Harbor Sunroad and Seaforth Boat Rentals, which offer travel and recreation options close to the restaurant.