Islamorada Fish Company

Reviews

• KL

  Kathy Langdon

  Apr 17, 2026
  5.0
  We have had wonderful service many times with Bryan and Eve as our servers. Managers always kind and checking on us . We have also had the pleasure of having the servers Danielle and Sal . They have given as great service. This restaurant has such excellent service. Servers and Managers are the best!
• MH

  Milton Hernandez

  Apr 6, 2026
  1.0
  This restaurant is a total joke! Needs to be shut down! There was no host, so we sat down, there was no greeting from anyone! The waiter was just walking around clueless and the cooks where just standing there and laughing, it took 15 mins for our DRINKS, not food to be placed on the table and the drink orders where totally incorrect! Then 45 mins later still no food, I literally got up, went to the kitchen and cancelled the order myself. I talked to the manager and she was to me not very caring or trying to get to the bottom of why it took toooooooo lllloooonnnggg!!!! It was my first experience and last and most likely will not ever return again to this resturant at all. Guess what guys! I went to the cheesecake factory down the street, it took 10 mins to get sat down, drinks within 4 mins, and 15 mins for food on the table! That was a total of 29 mins! And it took you guys 15 mins just to get the drinks! and we had to walk to the waiter to get us the menus! What a joke!
• MN

  Michelle Nealeigh

  Mar 17, 2026
  2.0
  We ordered shrimp tacos and country fried steak. Both meals were dissatisfying they lacked flavor and just wasn’t worth the cost. Also the restaurant itself such as tables and booth seats seemed unkept and dirty. I will not be eating here again.
• JE

  Jonathon “Delta” Estrada

  Mar 15, 2026
  5.0
  It was a great place to stop and eat. Food: Im a person that will NOT eat something if it doesnt taste good. So ill be 💯 %. I had the Gatorade bites. Biting into it took me back to Larose, Louisiana. Just memories. And im here for it. The sauce that accompanies it was great. I opted for the Pick 2 with my choices including the Hake (haven't had in a while to be honest) which was really flavorful. With the chips. Tar tar sauce on point. Lemon wedge was included. Second option was the Coconut Shrimp - this was was good and gone withing tje 2 monite I had it at the table. We opted to drink a fish bowl. It was GREAT. The littel gummies inside nice touch. 👌 Desert was a Cheesecake that was DELICIOUS. Also had a Coconit ice cream served with pineapple 10/10 Service: This was above amd beyond. I am one of the people who BASE an entire restaurant around how good the server/waiter/waitress are. SAL was on point, very amicable, and was social with us without overdoing it. Our interaction woth him felt genuine and really pleasurable. We definitely will return this is a but far for us but because of the AMAZING service he gave us. Its somewhere we will come back ona monthly basis. Thanks SAL!!!!
• MR

  Marsha Jo Rousseau

  Mar 8, 2026
  5.0
  We had great service and wonderful food. Our server Salvador was friendly and very attentive. My husband had fish &chips and I had elk sliders with sweet potato fries. Both were perfectly cooked and hot when it arrived. Thank you Salvador for the great experience!