Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• JN

  John Nguyen

  Mar 3, 2026
  4.0
  I ordered a Large Epic Stuffed Crust Pizza from Papa John's Pizza & it definitely delivered on flavor & portion size. First off, the stuffed crust is no joke. Each slice had that thick, golden-brown edge with gooey melted cheese baked right inside. When you pull it apart, the cheese stretches perfectly & tastes rich without being overly salty. It’s soft on the inside with just the right amount of crisp on the outside. For toppings, I went all in: grilled chicken, Canadian bacon, sausage, onions, green peppers & mushrooms on an Alfredo sauce base. The balance was impressive. The grilled chicken was tender & not dried out, the Canadian bacon added a nice smoky-sweet contrast & the sausage brought a nice savory kick. The veggies tasted fresh, especially the green peppers with a slight crunch along with the mushrooms being well-cooked & not soggy. The onions added just enough sharpness to cut through the cheese & meats. The pizza was generously loaded without feeling sloppy & every slice had a good distribution of toppings. You can tell from the thick layers of melted cheese on top that they didn’t skimp. It’s definitely a hearty & filling pizza, as one or two slices will certainly satisfy most people! The only reason I’m giving 4 stars instead of 5 is that the crust while delicious, was a bit heavier than expected, so it might be too much for someone looking for a lighter meal. However, if you tend to lean more towards indulgent comfort food, then this decadent pizza will certainly hit the spot! Overall, a solid choice for a fully loaded stuffed crust pizza in Pico Rivera, as I would not hesitate to order it again!
• MS

  Murat Selçuklu

  Feb 10, 2026
  5.0
  Great taste.
• PM

  Patrick Malloy

  Jan 22, 2026
  1.0
  I'M NOT SURE WHAT HAPPENED TO THIS STORE BECAUSE THEY USED TO BE GREAT! FRESH TOPPINGS, PLENTY OF CHEESE AND PERFECT SAUCE AND I HAD ABSOLUTELY NO PROBLEMS. BUT NOW THE PIZZA SUCKS!! THE PEPPERONI TASTED FUNNY, HARDLY ANY CHEESE ON ONE OF THE PIZZAS THAT HAD A VERY SKIMPY AMOUNT OF TOPPINGS AND FOR SOME REASON BOTH PIZZAS HAD AN UNUSUAL TASTE. TYPICALLY I CAN TASTE EACH TOPPING AND THEY WERE ALWAYS FRESH BUT NOW EVERYTHING HAD A FUNKY TASTE AND I HAD TO THROW BOTH PIZZAS IN THE TRASH. I DON'T KNOW WHAT HAPPENED BUT IT LOOKS LIKE I HAVE TO FIND A DIFFERENT PIZZA SHOP.
• JD

  Jeepin dirty

  Jan 8, 2026
  5.0
  Can be busy at times, but thats because they make good pizza! Can't complain. Its the only pizza spot I order from..
• LW

  Lisa W

  Jan 7, 2026
  5.0
  The worker was very nice lady. It was nice and clean in there. I asked her to please cut the pizza and squares what she did with no problem and I appreciate her doing that. Delicious pizza I must say my first time.