Many customers praised the food as delicious, fresh, and authentic, with specific mentions of tacos, burritos, and other menu items.
Service
Overall, service was noted as friendly and welcoming, though some reviews highlighted issues with slow service and order accuracy.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as having a chill and welcoming vibe, making it a good spot for families and casual dining.
Value
Customers appreciated the generous portions and reasonable prices, especially during special promotions like Taco Tuesdays.
Inconsistencies
Some reviews pointed out inconsistencies in food quality and service, with a few customers experiencing disappointing meals or service.
44
47tigger
Jan 5, 2026
3.0
I was happy to get a last minute order in before they closed. However, the flan tastes bitter and burrito is soggy. I asked if I could have the toppings on the side and the person on the phone said it doesn't come with toppings. I got home, opened the bag and saw that the sour cream, guac, tomato, lettuce, and sauce were all on top of my burrito which I didn't want because it would be soggy.
The flavor is good, I would recommend the burrito if you order dine in.
GS
G SR
Dec 22, 2025
5.0
Love love love the food, everything was freshly made. The person serving us seemed to know everyone who visited the place, maybe small city vibes or he has an amazing amazing memory. The staff was super welcoming and patient, overall the vibe helped us continue our little happy day! Would recommend going here especially for the tacos and margaritas!!!
PB
Pj Burch
Dec 18, 2025
5.0
Just moved to town three months ago have eaten here about five times they haven’t disappointed. Service is good Very chill atmosphere
CK
cindy klein
Dec 4, 2025
5.0
Delicious!
KH
KM Hodge
Nov 15, 2025
5.0
Always fun to go here! Great service and mild salsa and tacos 🌮 🌮 🌮 🌮!
Taco Tuesdays! Ground Heffer is best! Quick delivery and hot!
Frequently Asked Questions About Carmela's Mexican Restaurant
What are the opening hours of Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
Carmela's Mexican Restaurant is open every day from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Does Carmela's Mexican Restaurant offer delivery and pickup services?
Yes, the restaurant offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Is Carmela's Mexican Restaurant open on holidays like New Year's Day?
No, Carmela's Mexican Restaurant is closed on New Year's Day and similar holidays as specified in their holiday hours.
Where is Carmela's Mexican Restaurant located?
It is located at 1701 Central Avenue, McKinleyville, CA 95519, USA.
What types of cuisine does Carmela's Mexican Restaurant serve?
The restaurant serves Mexican, Tex-Mex, burritos, tacos, as well as options for breakfast, brunch, and vegetarian meals.
Where can I find the menu and order from Carmela's Mexican Restaurant online?
You can view the menu and place orders via their website at https://eatcarmelas.com/menu.
What is the price range of Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
The restaurant has a moderate price range labeled as 'TWO'.
As a customer, how can the nearby Chevron gas stations help me when visiting Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
You can refuel your vehicle at nearby Chevron stations such as Chevron Station Mckinleyville before or after dining at Carmela's, making your trip convenient for both food and fuel needs.
Are there any nearby coffee shops where I can relax before or after dining at Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, Sutters Mudd Coffee Company is a nearby coffee shop where you can enjoy a coffee break before or after your meal at Carmela's.
What other Mexican restaurants are close to Carmela's Mexican Restaurant for customers interested in variety?
Nearby Mexican restaurants include Luzmila's Mexican Restaurant and Aztec Grill, offering additional options for Mexican cuisine lovers.