Mixed reviews on pizza quality; some customers find it excellent while others describe it as bland or not authentic.
Service Experience
Customer service is inconsistent; some reviews praise friendly staff while others report rude or unprofessional behavior.
Cleanliness
Generally noted as clean, but some customers mention unclean tables and a lack of attention to detail.
Pricing
Prices are considered high by some customers, especially given the quality of food and service.
Menu Variety
Customers appreciate the variety of menu options, including pizza by the slice and specialty items.
EA
evan abrahams
1 day ago
5.0
We ordered a few things:
Chicken pesto pizza: Absolutely delicious for pesto lovers.
Spicy pepperoni pizza with pineapple: Super spicy but tasted amazing with the pineapple.
Spicy Nana Pasta: Tastes just how you'd imagine a spicy pink sauce to taste. Perfect.
Garlic Cheesy Bread: Can't go wrong here.
Meatballs: Excellent flavor and really great marinara sauce.
Their portions are really large, and definitely worth the price. Scratches that local NY pizza itch, and would definitely come back. You must try this place!
MM
marvingoose
Nov 18, 2025
5.0
Went vegetarian pizza to accommodate a friend. What a treat, still delicious!
DS
Dustin Stewart
Nov 14, 2025
2.0
I don’t know how I’ve never reviewed this place…we went here about a year ago and had truly the worst pizza I have ever had in my life. We didn’t even make it through half of the pizza. We lived in New York and it’s not even one of those like “not great because but it’s cheap” sort of slices. It’s just bad and nothing like thin sliced new York pizza. And it’s more expensive. Unfortunately I think nobody has told the owner this.
SM
Stevie Mack
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
One of my new favorite places! Rarely to find a pizza place in LA with that authentic New York crust....they got it!
KG
Kuroi G
Oct 30, 2025
1.0
Below average pizza. Crust was super thick, not new york style at all. Got half and half of turkey sausage and spinach artichoke. The cheeses were not properly melted. Overall very bland. Meat side barely had meat on it. Would not return.
Frequently Asked Questions About Mike's New York Pizzeria
What are the regular business hours for Mike's New York Pizzeria?
Mike's New York Pizzeria is open from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and from 11:00 AM to 10:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Does Mike's New York Pizzeria offer delivery services?
Yes, Mike's New York Pizzeria offers both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Where is Mike's New York Pizzeria located?
It is located at 5035 W Slauson Ave, Los Angeles, CA 90056, United States.
Can I order food online from Mike's New York Pizzeria?
Yes, you can view the menu and place orders online at https://mikesnewyorkpizzeria.com/menu.
What types of cuisine and food categories does Mike's New York Pizzeria specialize in?
They specialize in pizza, Italian cuisine, chicken wings, gluten-free options, salads, and catering services.
What are the takeout hours for Mike's New York Pizzeria?
Takeout is available from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM Monday through Thursday and Sunday, and until 10:00 PM on Fridays and Saturdays.
Are there any healthy dining options near Mike's New York Pizzeria?
Yes, nearby you can find Simply Salad, a salad bar and delicatessen, and Qwench Juice Bar and DRNK Coffee and Tea, which offers smoothies and health foods, perfect for a healthy meal or drink before or after your visit.
What other food options are available near Mike's New York Pizzeria?
Nearby food options include Firehouse Subs for sandwiches and McDonald's for fast food, offering variety around your visit to Mike's.
Are there any fitness or recreational facilities near Mike's New York Pizzeria?
Yes, 24 Hour Fitness - La Cienega, CA is nearby, providing a great place to work out before or after enjoying a meal at the pizzeria.
What is the contact phone number for Mike's New York Pizzeria?
You can reach Mike's New York Pizzeria by phone at +1 323-815-1656.