Customers praised the fish and chips for being fresh, crispy, and flavorful, though some noted inconsistency in quality.
Service
The staff received positive remarks for being friendly and accommodating, enhancing the overall dining experience.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as having a quaint, authentic vibe reminiscent of a British pub, though some reviews mentioned cleanliness issues.
Value
While many found the food to be reasonably priced, a few customers felt that the portions and pricing did not match their expectations.
Consistency
Several long-time patrons expressed concerns about the restaurant's consistency over the years, with some meals not meeting their previous standards.
IH
Israel Cano (Hurcules)
6 days ago
5.0
The large bucket of fish combo.
KH
Kellie Huyck
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
Great food
TZ
Todd Zuella
Nov 13, 2025
5.0
Best fish and chips ever. Used to drive from Orange County just for it! Hush puppies are other worldly
OS
O Santana
Nov 6, 2025
4.0
I always get the clam chowder, it’s good. Nothing to rave about but still good. Service is always nice, and place is always clean. I suggest Add long seasoning to the fries to make them better.
MM
Melinda
Oct 5, 2025
2.0
I’m sorry to say this as I am OG Lompocian going to Alfies since the 80’s when they were near Gemini theatre … They are just NOT CONSISTENT these days … sometimes ALL fresh others NOT! Some pieces, Dry fish and the fries were horrible … Tip: NEED TO CHANGE OUT THE OIL — I know it’s expensive but I’d rather have fresh oil and food, paying more than a stomach ache and food poisoning. I wish restaurants in Lompoc would stop cutting corners for dollars 😢