Enjoy New York slices in the California sun. Surf Rider Pizza Co. serves east coast-style pies with classic wide-cut slices, a thin and crispy crust and fresh toppings. Surf Rider pies are baked fresh daily with our hand-tossed dough along with our delicious calzones, sandwiches, salads and more.
Customers generally praised the pizza for its flavor and variety, though some noted inconsistencies in crust texture and cooking.
Customer Service
Feedback on service was mixed; while many appreciated friendly staff, others reported rude interactions and long wait times.
Atmosphere
The restaurant is described as having a fun, casual vibe, suitable for families and groups, though some found it crowded and noisy.
Value for Money
Opinions on pricing varied, with some customers feeling it was overpriced for the quality, while others found it reasonable for the portion sizes.
Dietary Accommodations
The business received positive remarks for accommodating dietary restrictions and offering a variety of options.
BJ
B J
Nov 13, 2025
4.0
One of our favorite places to come for pizza. 2 slices and a drink. Great pizza. Love the outdoor seating and especially the indoor/outdoor bar-style seating. Can be popular with large groups and kids.
SA
Stacy Albert
Nov 12, 2025
5.0
The pizza was delicious!!! I loved that they had gluten free crusts that tasted great! Sooo many different toppings & options available too! Fun, laid back atmosphere. I loved the outdoor seating area!
SB
Scott Barber
Nov 11, 2025
5.0
Servers were fabulous. Pizza, salad, and garlic knots were great. Pizza by the slice.
KW
Katherine Wager
Nov 8, 2025
5.0
Shout out to Carlos, the manager who helped us make our Soccer Party happen. So easy to order at the county, all of the staff was stellar, even when super packed and busy. The pesto bread was incredible.
DL
Daniel Ledesma
Oct 14, 2025
5.0
Came to this spot after the gym to watch some playoff baseball and this place honestly has some of the best pizza in San Diego. Slices are large and generous in portion and they offer other things like garlic knots, salads, and wings. TVs all around and a bar on the other side for that sports bar feel. Outside area is also abundant for those bigger groups
They have this really good deal for two slices and a fountain drink or 16oz beer for around $16.00 before tip.
Finally, downtown in general has a lot of other bars you can hit after if you're looking to bar crawl.
Surf Rider Pizza serves east coast-style pies with classic wide-cut slices, thin and crispy crust, and fresh toppings.
What are the operating hours of Surf Rider Pizza?
Surf Rider Pizza is open daily from 11:30 AM to 9:00 PM.
Where is Surf Rider Pizza located?
Surf Rider Pizza is located at 8381 La Mesa Blvd, La Mesa, CA 91942, USA.
Can I view the menu online for Surf Rider Pizza?
Yes, you can view the menu online at https://www.surfrider-pizza.com/menu-pizza/.
Is there an option to order pizza online from Surf Rider Pizza?
Yes, you can order online at https://order.toasttab.com/online/surfrider.pizza.
What languages are supported at Surf Rider Pizza?
Surf Rider Pizza supports English language services.
What is the contact phone number for Surf Rider Pizza?
You can contact Surf Rider Pizza at +1 619-340-1270.
Are there any antique stores near Surf Rider Pizza?
Yes, nearby antique stores include Park Estate Company Antiques & Estate Sales, Favorite Things, Antiques @ The Village, and Coin Haus.
What dining options are available near Surf Rider Pizza?
Nearby dining options include Johnny B's Burgers Brew and Spirits, Gingham, Casa Gabriela, Gio Bistro and Wine Bar, Centifonti's Bar & Restaurant, BO-beau kitchen + garden, Sheldon’s Service Station, Curbside Eatery & Drinkery, Aubrey Rose Tea Room, and Coin Haus.
What nearby spots can I visit for relaxation and wellness before or after dining at Surf Rider Pizza?
You can visit Healing Therapies for physical therapy and health food, Salon Radiance and VEYRA Beauty for hair services, Beleza Waxing & Skincare Lounge for waxing and skincare treatments.