Customers praised the pizza for its taste and freshness, though some noted inconsistencies in crust quality and ingredient distribution.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service was mixed; while many appreciated friendly staff, several reviews highlighted rude service and delivery issues.
Pricing
Some customers felt the prices were high for the quality received, with complaints about value for money and extra charges for credit card use.
Cleanliness and Environment
The establishment was generally noted for being clean, contributing positively to the dining experience.
JP
JUDY PEARSON
Nov 27, 2025
5.0
Best tasting pizza in town.
JS
Jerrell Sherod
Nov 13, 2025
5.0
Friendly, professional, great customer service and the food was great definately going back for more
LB
Lance Broderick
Oct 27, 2025
4.0
Place is clean. Counter attendant very helpful and patient. Quality of food is an old original, nothing special and nothing new. Great for old fashion football game, hanging with friends, or when you just need a lot of food. Food quality is the same as years ago, so no depreciation there. When you are simply hungry, go Red Baron Pizza. Service was pretty fast, no hesitation. Old fashion good customer service.
BR
brittany rose
Aug 25, 2025
1.0
The whole center of the pizza is basically soup. The bottom of the center is totally soaked in oil which makes the crust weak when you go to pull a slice and you end up with a pile of cheese and sauce mush. I’m good on Red Barons over priced pizza at this point. $50 bucks for basically half of an edible pizza. Thanks guys!
GT
Gabriel Telford
Aug 9, 2025
1.0
I have waited almost an hour for my pizza to arrive and they told me that it would only take 44 minutes to arrive which is insane when they are 15 minutes away from my home once the pizza arrives i will never ever order from Red Barrens again i have spent 29 dollars for a large pizza never again ordering from this