At dawn, Noah’s bakes up a wide variety of fresh bagels ready to be topped with our signature double-whipped shmear or made into delicious breakfast sandwiches featuring cage-free eggs. We also serve a wide variety of lunch options for kids and adults alike, plus sides of sweets, hashbrowns, coffee and espresso. We offer an extensive catering menu and now you can skip the line by ordering ahead in the Noah’s mobile app.
Customers generally praised the bagels and sandwiches for their taste and freshness, though some noted inconsistencies in preparation and quality.
Customer Service
Feedback on customer service was mixed; while some praised the friendly staff, others reported rude behavior and poor service experiences.
Cleanliness
Several reviews mentioned cleanliness issues, with some customers describing the restaurant as dirty or in disrepair.
Order Accuracy
Many customers expressed frustration with incorrect orders and missing items, indicating a need for improvement in order fulfillment.
Atmosphere
The atmosphere received mixed reviews, with some enjoying the vibe while others noted it felt unwelcoming or chaotic.
SP
Sir Perry
3 days ago
5.0
Noah’s NY Bagels is a solid choice when you’re craving a classic bagel with plenty of options. The bagels are fresh, chewy, and flavorful, with a wide variety of spreads, sandwiches, and breakfast combos to choose from. Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or a coffee to-go, it’s convenient and consistently satisfying.
Service is usually fast and friendly, and the menu has something for everyone, from simple classics to more filling breakfast sandwiches. Overall, Noah’s NY Bagels is a dependable spot for a tasty, no-fuss breakfast or lunch. 🥯☕
JP
Janmesh Patel
Aug 31, 2025
2.0
Service and everyone inside were great, this rating is heavily influenced by the food. Saw the sign saying “New York” bagels so expected the same or similar quality. These bagels are an embarrassment to NYC bagels. The bagel wasn’t toasted enough and the cream cheese was barely visible, this has to be the thinnest layer I’ve ever seen. I would say the bagels are average at best, can get similar quality or better at other national chains.
What are the operating hours of Noah's NY Bagels at 5249 Hazel Ave, Fair Oaks?
Noah's NY Bagels is open every day from 6:00 AM to 2:00 PM.
Does Noah's NY Bagels offer breakfast and what are some signature breakfast items?
Yes, they serve breakfast including fresh-baked bagels with signature double-whipped shmear and cage-free egg sandwiches.
Can I order ahead to skip the line at Noah's NY Bagels?
Yes, you can order ahead using the Noah's mobile app available on both Android and iOS.
What are the available payment options at Noah's NY Bagels?
You can pay with American Express, Discover, Mastercard, Visa, Apple Pay, Android Pay, Samsung Pay, cash, contactless payments, and debit cards.
Does Noah's NY Bagels provide catering services?
Yes, an extensive catering menu is available for groups.
Is there parking available when visiting Noah's NY Bagels?
Yes, there is free street parking as well as free parking lots nearby.
What options does Noah's NY Bagels offer for dining?
They offer dine-in, takeout, delivery, in-store pickup, and drive-through service.
Which nearby places can I visit after enjoying a meal at Noah's NY Bagels?
You can visit nearby spots such as Jamba for smoothies, Baskin Robbins for ice cream, or Cookie Plug Fair Oaks for bakery treats.
Are there nearby places to shop or run errands around Noah's NY Bagels?
Yes, the Madison Marketplace shopping center, T.J.Maxx department store, and SAFE Credit Union are nearby for shopping and banking needs.
How can nearby transit and amenities help when visiting Noah's NY Bagels?
Nearby amenities like Raley's Supermarkets and Wells Fargo Bank provide convenience, while nearby fast food spots like McDonald's and Del Taco offer alternative dining options around the area.