Customers praised the delicious and authentic Mexican food, with specific mentions of burritos, tacos, and mole dishes, although some noted inconsistencies in flavor and preparation.
Service
Service received mixed reviews; while many highlighted friendly and attentive staff, others reported long wait times and issues with order accuracy.
Value
The restaurant is recognized for its reasonable prices and large portion sizes, making it a popular choice for lunch and dinner.
Atmosphere
The dining environment is generally described as comfortable and welcoming, though some reviews mentioned a need for improvements in decor.
KR
Kimberly Lonjin (Kimberly Lonjin, RN)
Dec 30, 2025
5.0
Never disappoints
KW
Kelly Walter
Dec 28, 2025
5.0
Maria was very friendly! Great service, delicious food! Kid friendly
GS
greg sounhein
Dec 17, 2025
5.0
Best place to eat. Great prices, great food and lots of parking
JK
Jayce Kelley
Nov 19, 2025
5.0
Their burritos are very good, but I personally like their chimichangas the best.
CB
Carol Bach
Nov 5, 2025
3.0
The margaritas were made with bottled mix and ZERO tequila. I would’ve sent it back but the server seemed to be having a hard day. The vegetarian tacos consist of 1 item - I chose 1 tofu and 1 spinach - on a small, bare flour tortilla and nothing else. No onions and cilantro, no lettuce, no beans or grilled veggies that would’ve greatly improved the taco, just a few cubes of tofu or a few spinach leaves and nothing else. I would’ve sent rate this place 2 ⭐️ but my companions were happy with their meals: shrimp fajitas and a mole burrito.
Frequently Asked Questions About Carmela's Mexican Restaurant
What are the regular opening hours of Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
Carmela's Mexican Restaurant is open daily from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Does Carmela's Mexican Restaurant offer delivery and in-store pickup?
Yes, the restaurant provides both in-store pickup and delivery services.
Can I order takeout from Carmela's Mexican Restaurant and what are the hours?
Takeout is available every day from 11:00 AM to 9:00 PM.
Where is Carmela's Mexican Restaurant located?
The restaurant is located at 1288 G St, Arcata, CA 95521, United States.
Where can I view Carmela's Mexican Restaurant menu online?
You can view the menu at https://eatcarmelas.com/menu.
How can I contact Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
You can reach them by phone at +1 707-822-5200.
What types of cuisine and dining options does Carmela's Mexican Restaurant offer?
They serve Mexican and Tex-Mex cuisine including burritos, tacos, and breakfast options, and offer a family-friendly dining experience.
What nearby attractions can I visit before or after dining at Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
You can visit the Natural History Museum and the HSU Natural History Museum, both nearby and great for exploring local history and science exhibits.
Are there other dining options near Carmela's Mexican Restaurant?
Yes, nearby eateries include Cafe Phoenix & SMOKED Backyard BBQ, Pho Hoang Vietnamese Restaurant, Ramone's Bakery & Cafe, and Wildberries Marketplace which also offers groceries and bakery items.
What services are available nearby Carmela's Mexican Restaurant for banking and shopping needs?
Near the restaurant, you'll find Redwood Capital Bank Arcata for financial services and shopping options like Emerald City Laundry Co and Norman's Dry Cleaners for laundry and dry cleaning.