Blue Bayou is one of the more upscale dining options at Disneyland but doesn’t sacrifice the elements of magic and whimsy that the theme park is known for. Located in New Orleans Square, the Blue Bayou restaurant transports its guests to an evening patio on a Louisiana waterfront. The sky is a saturated cobalt blue and adorned with the light of fireflies and paper lanterns. It can take months to secure a reservation here and up to half a year if you want a table right next to the water. And it’s easy to see why. The Pirates of the Caribbean ride drifts right next to the dining area, so waterside tables get a super unique, exclusive experience. On my first visit, I sat right next to the restroom in the very back of the restaurant, but I am proud to share that on THIS visit, I moved up one whole row (still next to the restroom though).
Our server, Jordan, was great! He was nice, funny, and super on top of everything. He also convinced us to order everything on the menu that we were on the fence about, and two cocktails later, we couldn’t be more grateful.
I had the Sweet Peach Iced Tea with Rum, which was amazing. After a whole day consuming sweets, I was looking for something refreshing with a little bitterness to it, and this drink did just that. It was not too sweet, and the tea flavor had just the right amount of bitterness. For those looking for a sweeter cocktail, the Hurricane is definitely the way to go. Light and dark rum with passionfruit and citrus juices. This tasted like pure nectar, like orange juice from the Garden of Eden itself.
I had the crab cakes for my appetizer, which, at $18, came with 2 crab cakes and a small apple arugula salad. I’m a bit on the fence about the value as the portion only came with 2 crab cakes and the size of each crab cake was smaller than expected. If I were to nitpick further, I thought that the outside of the crab cakes were a bit overdone and dry. But other than that, the flavor was good and the inside of the cakes were still enjoyable.
For my entree, I had the prime rib, which came with mashed potatoes and roasted broccolini. The steak was tender and juicy, and I liked the peppercorn demi-glace sauce. Just be careful as there is a salt crust, and my first bite was only that, which was a bit of a nasty surprise.
One of my friends got the Prix-Fixe menu, which came with a dark chocolate pistachio cheesecake. At this point, we were all stuffed, so we shared it. It did not taste like pistachio, which is what I loved about it. It was actually a pretty good cheesecake - not too sweet, tangy, and the bitterness of the dark chocolate balanced everything out.
Speaking of being stuffed, I will say that the portion sizes of the entrees are huge. I was struggling to get down my last bites of steak, and my friend who got the entree-sized portion of the gumbo was marooned on gumbo island. To be super honest, the gumbo was delicious. Like it was really good. Like it was better than the ribeye and the prime rib, good. The flavors were wonderful, and the dish was perfectly seasoned. If you are not that hungry, I would highly suggest you stick to the appetizer-sized portion.
In the end, I decided to give 5 stars to Blue Bayou because for a theme park dining experience, this was very good. I could definitely see myself coming back, but would probably opt to share dishes next time as the portion sizes are very big. I hope that I will be able to sit one additional row closer to the water next time as well.