New York Bagels 'N Bialys - Shea

Reviews

• JS

  Jamie Strope

  Apr 6, 2026
  5.0
  This review is just for your google photos. Phenomenal! Thank you so much. I am someone who likes to look at the google pictures of the food before I go to a restaurant. Everything looks so amazing and there is so much to look at. I will be in soon!
• NV

  Nielsen Village

  Mar 29, 2026
  5.0
  Fun place, quick service, lots of food 😋. Did breakfast and offerings were wonderful, hard to choose from. Large restaurant with table service. Very pleased.
• BG

  Barney Goldstein

  Mar 19, 2026
  2.0
  Our usual go to place for bagels (NYC Cafe) was closed so we checked out this bagel establishment. There is no comparison in terms of quality and price. The bagels (and bialys) at NY Bagels 'N Bialys were dry, hard, smaller, and not particularly tasty. In fact, they tasted stale. Such a disappointing contrast to the NYC Cafe bagels that are much larger, very soft, delicious, and very fresh. Price-wise, NY Bagels 'N Bialys were more expensive than NYC Cafe. The former charged $20.99 for a dozen bagels. The latter charged $18.99 for a "Bakers Dozen" in which you receive 13 bagels for the price of 12. The price for tubs of cream cheese were on par. I will say that the service was fine. I have no complaints about that aspect of my experience there. However, given the poorer quality and higher price, I will never return to New York Bagels 'N Bialys. NYC Cafe is the go to place for top rate bagels at a reasonable price.
• JL

  Jupiter Lost

  Mar 15, 2026
  3.0
  Just ok overall. For newcomers, not clear whether to wait at front or get in line for cashier to get dat at a table (the latter being what to do, although it makes no sense). Food is ok, nothing special. Service is ok, nothing special, definitely not fantastic. They did have clean bathrooms. (Picture note: I asked for no tomatoes, capers, or onion...they're not missing. I got what I requested.)
• BL

  Bob Leitz

  Mar 11, 2026
  1.0
  HOLD THE MAYO!🤮 For the Manager of a “NY” Jewish style “deli” to show attitude to a customer who was a bit disturbed that your employee slathered mayonnaise all over a corned beef on bialy sandwich is a laugher! I’d be concerned as well that other customers might overhear such an act! In New York, you have to sign a disclaimer if you would dare to order mayo on a corned beef or pastrami sandwich. Good luck! If you do happen to stop in New York Bagels & Bialys, do tell them to “hold the mayo!”

Frequently Asked Questions About New York Bagels 'N Bialys - Shea