Mastro's Steakhouse

Reviews

• JR

  Jeff Ralston

  4 days ago
  5.0
  My wife and I had dinner on Saturday evening and everything was fantastic! My only critiques are that the napkins we used were very thin and had a musty smell and we sat at a high top in the bar and the tablecloths were too long.
• TA

  Talal Almotawaa

  Apr 5, 2026
  5.0
  Absolutely love this place. The atmosphere is always on point—great energy, clean, and welcoming every single time. The manager really stands out, making sure everything runs smoothly and that guests feel taken care of. You can tell there’s real pride in how this place is run. From the service to the overall vibe, this steakhouse never fails. Definitely one of my go-to spots.
• AI

  Asia Italia

  Apr 4, 2026
  5.0
  First of all we called 📞 for a dinner reservation, but we did not expect that they will make it a very special night for us 💥 when we arrived early the hostess seated us and the waitress Olivia with her right hand helper handed us the personalized menu 💞 and even gave me a copy to bring home, it was cool! Then She explained the whole menu and of course very knowledgeable on wines💗 We’ve been to a different high end a fancy restaurant in different state but this is the best one and unforgettable experience! For the price it was worth it and delicious 🤤 cook to a perfection steak 🥩 and perfect wine pairing 🍷 We own a restaurant in small town of Wyoming so like to go to the different places to dine 😊but The ambiance, service , food and overall experience is truly a 5 💫 of this one 💥 Thank you for making our 17th years Anniversary memorable one.
• RR

  RStevens

  Mar 30, 2026
  3.0
  I went in expecting a solid steakhouse experience because of the Maestro’s reputation , but the whole night ended up being pretty underwhelming. First off, the noise level was hard to ignore. The dining room was so loud that holding a normal conversation felt like a challenge. Between the clatter of dishes and the loud music that didn’t quite fit the atmosphere, it never really settled into that comfortable, upscale steakhouse vibe you’d hope for. As for the food, it didn’t redeem the experience. I ordered my steak medium, but it came out noticeably overcooked—closer to well-done than anything else. It lacked the juiciness and flavor you expect when you’re paying steakhouse prices. The sides were fine, but just fine—nothing particularly memorable or worth going back for. Even the appetizers and drinks felt like they were going through the motions rather than trying to impress. Service wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t great either. Everything felt a bit rushed and impersonal, like they were trying to turn tables quickly rather than create a relaxed dining experience. Overall, nothing was terrible, but nothing stood out in a good way either. Between the noise, the overcooked steak, and the generally mediocre food, it’s not a place I’d be in a hurry to revisit.
• KH

  Keegan Huerta

  Mar 30, 2026
  5.0
  If you're looking for a top notch steak, this is absolutely the place. Steaks are perfectly grilled and placed on a 500 degree plate before being served. The sides are delicious and big enough for two or even three people to share. The old fashioned was a perfect blend of whiskey, bitters, and sugar. My absolutely favorite part of the experience was the desert, the buttered cake and homemade whipped cream was lights out. Be sure to schedule a reservation well in advance as this place can get busy.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mastro's Steakhouse