New York Bagels N Bialys

Reviews

• MR

  Matt Ribeiro

  4 days ago
  5.0
  We came in for bagels this morning and had a lovely experience. Service was fast and very friendly, food was fresh. I love my everything bagel with jalapeno cream cheese. Definitely will come back.
• SL

  Sasha Leviyev

  Jan 4, 2026
  2.0
  Came in to order a regular turkey sandwich on a bagel to-go. The total came out to $18 for a basic sandwich (no avocado, bacon, etc, just turkey) with chips on the side which is a bit egregious… I was hungry so I paid the price without comment and left a tip as well. It took over 10 minutes to make the sandwich which was surprising given that maybe half the tables in the restaurant were occupied, but I waited patiently and someone eventually brought my order out. Once I got to my car, I opened the box to make sure everything was in order before leaving. Believe it or not, there was no turkey in the turkey sandwich… at all. Just lettuce, tomatoes, and mayo. So I went back in and they fixed the sandwich. Now to the review of the food itself. The sesame bagel was fresh and tasty, but that’s all that was impressive. The turkey was dry and the sandwich overall was pretty underwhelming. If you’re looking for a simple turkey sandwich on a bagel, Einstein’s will do just fine for half the price.
• AW

  Aaron Wachtel

  Dec 17, 2025
  5.0
  The perfect breakfast spot
• TB

  Theo Bowser

  Nov 28, 2025
  5.0
  This place took over the old First Watch location and it did not disappoint at all. The pancake hash browns, the burgers, the BLT, absolutely phenomenal. Honestly, I am not sure what kind of magic they are cooking with back there, but everything that came out of that kitchen tasted like it was crafted by someone who genuinely loves food and wants you to be happy. Highly recommend. Bring an appetite and maybe some self control, because once you start eating here, you are going to want everything on the menu.
• LG

  Lee Guy

  Nov 22, 2025
  5.0
  If you're looking for an authentic slice of New York deli flavor transported to the Arizona desert, the bagels and bialys at New York Bagels 'N Bialys on Hayden Road are simply non-negotiable. These are the real deal: perfectly boiled, wonderfully chewy, and baked with that classic crust that makes a true bagel. From the everything bagel piled high with cream cheese to the satisfyingly savory bialys, the quality of the food here is consistently outstanding—the best in the Valley, arguably. Come prepared to wait, and manage your expectations for the staff. The outstanding lox and the hearty deli sandwiches are worth the wait, but the slow service is definitely the price you pay for this East Coast perfection.

Frequently Asked Questions About New York Bagels N Bialys