America's Hometown Pizza Place™ since 1958. Home of the Original Thin and Original Pizza Buffet. Pizzas are hand-made daily with fresh dough. Choose from a variety of pizzas, pasta, salad, and desserts!
Service quality is inconsistent, with some customers praising attentive staff while others report poor service and unresponsive management.
Food Quality
Food quality varies significantly; while some customers enjoy the pizza and buffet, others complain about cold food, lack of variety, and cleanliness issues.
Cleanliness
Multiple reviews highlight cleanliness concerns, particularly regarding the salad bar and dining area.
Customer Experience
Overall customer experiences are mixed, with some enjoying their visits and others vowing not to return due to negative interactions.
CS
Curt Sanders
Jan 22, 2026
5.0
My daughter and I decided to have a pizza buffet and since we live in Jonesboro we were thinking about Mazzio's or Pizza inn. We remembered really liking the Larry's Pizza when it was in Jonesboro so we decided to make the drive to Paragould. Unfortunately it was closed because of MLK Day. So we drove down to Pizza inn and we're happy to see that it was open and completely packed. We actually got the only parking spot in the lot. We were a little concerned about the buffet not staying full but we were pleasantly surprised. Even with a packed restaurant the buffet had new pizzas coming out every couple of minutes. We were able to get all of our favorites except maybe a couple of specialty ones. It was a great experience and I will definitely be back because this Pizza inn seems to be better than the ones in Jonesboro.
LN
LaNatalie Norman
Jan 6, 2026
1.0
Worst experience ever. Went in ordered our drinks & our usual BBQ chicken pizza & veggie pizza both thin crust. Nothing on the bar to eat, 30 minutes later ask about our pizzas & they hadn't even started cooking them. So $35 for 3 soft drinks never got our pizza or a sorry.
PC
Patrick Callihan
Dec 28, 2025
5.0
Potato pizza was delicious.
JM
Jason Mcdaniel
Dec 17, 2025
1.0
Me and my family went to eat there a little after six pm, 12/17-25 all three of my family members who ate there we are all on individual toilets in the home, we had to stop three times so we didn’t mess ourselves. I paid 36$ for food poisoning, maybe a health inspector is in order. How ever Kaylen was our server, she busted her but multitasking, she did not stay still, she was awesome at her job no one else had the same energy she did. There was a 19 yr old or so behind the counter and a special needs girl asked if there were tomatoes for the salad bar and he said go ask someone else, that was his exact words. Not cool!!!!!!
FW
Felicia Whitworth
Dec 5, 2025
1.0
Only put one star because I have to in order to share a review. My husband literally walked in there at 9:30 pm and the man working on 12//05/25, white man with glasses, said they were closing while a young lady said they were open until 11 pm. Dude had an attitude. Maybe shouldn’t have an attitude with the people who bring you your goods. #Truckdriversmattertoo