When you're looking for a relaxing, wholesome brunch with a variety of delicious, healthy offerings, look no further than Stone Mill Cafe - Bentonville, your go-to Southern restaurant and cafe in Bentonville, AR. Our staff strives to create a cozy environment where you can feel at home. All of our recipes and dressings at our sandwich shop are made from scratch and have no preservatives. At our Southern restaurant, we offer a variety of soups, salads, sandwiches, breads, and more. If you're looking for a comfortable, affordable cafe to satisfy your many cravings, drop by Stone Mill Cafe today.
Mixed reviews on food quality; some dishes praised while others criticized for lack of flavor and high prices.
Service Experience
Customer service is generally friendly, but some reviews mention rude staff and inconsistent service.
Pricing Concerns
Many customers feel the prices are high for the quality and portion sizes of the food.
Atmosphere
The cafe has a cozy and inviting atmosphere, though some find it lacking in cleanliness at times.
Menu Variety
The menu offers a good variety of sandwiches and baked goods, but some customers desire more flavorful options.
CW
Charity Weaver
4 days ago
5.0
Delicious food! Im only disappointed TSA confiscated my souvenir jams, I was really looking forward to trying the Apple Cranberry butter. Next time..
TB
Todd Bashuk
Nov 15, 2025
4.0
First of all The food was very good and the service was adequate. I was very shocked when I got my bill for my lunch. I ordered a BLT sandwich cup of soup and a soda and the cost of my lunch was $26. I think that is an absurd price for a sandwich and a cup of soup after $26 the screen came up and the wanted a 18 to 26% tip I won’t be going back to Stone Mill bakery only because the price is exorbitant.
This was in person. Not on door dash
NW
Nikkole Waddell
Nov 8, 2025
3.0
Only giving three stars because of the excellent customer service. Food was just very..blah. I had high hopes for the chicken salad but I had to put mustard on it because it was just soo bland. Chicken dumpling soup wasn’t terrible but, again, no flavor. Oatmeal cookie was decent.
JH
Joe Hudgens
Nov 4, 2025
5.0
We shop the Stone Mill in Fayetteville but didn’t know there was one in Bentonville. We dropped our dog off for a groom and found this by accident. We showed up in between busy hours so there was only 4 old guys solving the world’s problems. We had the biscuit and gravy and it was delicious. We also picked up a couple loaves of their cranberry pecan bread (our favorite). The lady was super nice and the place was really nice. Will definitely go back and I highly recommend it.
AK
Abbie Kent
Nov 1, 2025
1.0
Worst food I’ve had in a long time! How does this have such good reviews?? Beyond bland!! We got take out because my husband didn’t want “hotel food” but this was no better than hotel food. The potatoes were bland with no seasoning whatsoever, the eggs were the weirdest looking and tasting (I’m hoping I don’t get sick) - it was so disappointing to have spent over $40. Fast food would have tasted better and been less expensive. Would never eat here again. :/