When you're looking for a relaxing, wholesome brunch with a variety of delicious, healthy offerings, look no further than Stone Mill Cafe - Bentonville, your go-to Southern restaurant and cafe in Bentonville, AR. Our staff strives to create a cozy environment where you can feel at home. All of our recipes and dressings at our sandwich shop are made from scratch and have no preservatives. At our Southern restaurant, we offer a variety of soups, salads, sandwiches, breads, and more. If you're looking for a comfortable, affordable cafe to satisfy your many cravings, drop by Stone Mill Cafe today.
Mixed reviews on food quality; some found it delicious while others described it as bland and overpriced.
Customer Service
Customer service received high praise for being friendly and accommodating, though some reported negative experiences.
Pricing
Many customers felt the prices were too high for the portion sizes and quality of food.
Atmosphere
The cafe has a cozy and inviting atmosphere, but some noted it felt run down.
CK
Candy King
3 days ago
4.0
We have made a 3 hour trip to this place 3 time and the last time was a tad disappointing the chicken salad was bland and very dry this time.
I will try again maybe just a bad day
SM
Suzanne Moore
Jan 3, 2026
5.0
The chicken salad sandwich was perfection! Most I’ve enjoyed a sandwich in as long as I can remember. Service was great! Highly recommend.
LL
Lyn (Lyn)
Jan 2, 2026
3.0
I was highly disappointed to find the pick 2 no longer includes a cookie and chips. This was the beauty in the pick 2. I paid $14 for half a sandwich and small cup of soup. Chicken salad sandwich was delicious but the broccoli cheese soup was orange, tasted like the burnt layer on the bottom of the pot and had a layer of oil sitting on top. 2 pieces of broccoli in it and mainly tasted like chicken broth. Pretty much paid for soup juice.
I love Stone Mill but I will no longer purchase from this location due to the ala cart implementation and the poor quality of soup. If the other locations have not gone ala cart, I highly recommend the Bentonville location go back to the way it was. People will talk and you will lose business I assure you. Really disappointed…
MJ
Madison J
Dec 21, 2025
5.0
Not sure why others are commenting such negative reviews. I don't feel the food is bland. It's not a gourmet restaurant. It's a quick sandwich and soup. It taste wonderful. The customer service is top tier. They will do their best to make it a positive experience for everyone. I've been a couple times and each time I've gone I've left very happy. They are always fairly busy but the food is coming as soon as I sit down after getting a drink most of the time. It's fast and a great place to sit with friends and family. Really amazing place.
BB
Brad Bundy
Dec 12, 2025
3.0
Extremely overpriced for the portions you receive. Not the same as Springdale location. I got the 1/2 sandwich and soup with water. Sandwich was half the size of the Springdale location and soup is limited to one flavor per day vs 3 at other locations. Literally was charged for extras that come with the meal at other locations I've been. For instance the cookie and chips. It cost me 4 dollars more than other locations and half the food. It seems this particular owner is taking advantage of the patrons in Bentonville. Thats too bad 👎 I wont return to this location. $17 for half sandwich and soup and I ordered water!!! My suggestion is save your money and go to the Springdale location.