TuscNY Pizza

Reviews

• SS

  Siege Salie

  6 days ago
  5.0
  It was a nice place to grab a quick slice of pizza. My son enjoyed the long bench seats. It gave him a lot of room to spread his toddler legs. I recommend the supreme pizza and would definitely eat here again.
• MW

  Michael West

  Feb 28, 2026
  5.0
  Pizza is great, I’m an avid pizza maker myself and this is the only place I’ve found in town to get “real” pizza.
• DB

  Daphne Boswell

  Feb 27, 2026
  5.0
  THE BEST NY style pizza in Tuscaloosa! Paul is Italian & originally from New Jersey & has searched this town for authentic pizza. He took me here for Valentine’s Dinner. We were so incredibly impressed! Savannah was awesome, the peach Bellini was perfect and the artichoke dip is amazing on the little pillows of warm pita bread. Then came the pizza…we had pepperoni and sausage New York style. The crust was so thin and crispy and the fresh sauce…makes my mouth water thinking of it! The tiramisu was delicious too! Everything was so good we ordered another 20” supreme to take home! Today I ordered takeout & it did not disappoint!!! Our new favorite place! 💕
• JB

  Jasmyne Baylor (Baylahhh)

  Feb 22, 2026
  5.0
  I absolutely lovedddd this pizza!! Make sure to get the biggest pie that have cause you’ll be upset once you’re done with it and want more and more lol Watch my full review on TikTok/ facebook yo_baylahhh
• CR

  Catherine Rice

  Feb 4, 2026
  2.0
  The service was great at TuscNY. Went there for lunch today with my brother. I ordered a small cheese pizza with thick crust. The crowd was very minimal for lunchtime. This was my first time eating here. I was not impressed with my pizza. There was very little cheese on my pizza- despite the fact that it was a cheese pizza. Mostly it was just sauce with very little cheese. The underside of the crust was very overdone almost burned and brick hard. I've eaten a lot of pizza in a lot of different places/ states and lived in Italy for 3 1/2 years where the pizza was divine. This pizza was just meh.

Frequently Asked Questions About TuscNY Pizza