Overall, customers praised the food quality, particularly the steaks and seafood, with many describing their meals as exceptional and flavorful.
Service Excellence
The service received high marks, with numerous reviews highlighting attentive, friendly, and knowledgeable staff who went above and beyond to enhance the dining experience.
Atmosphere
The restaurant's atmosphere was frequently described as charming and inviting, with many customers appreciating the outdoor seating and overall ambiance.
Pricing Concerns
Some customers expressed concerns about the pricing, noting that certain dishes felt overpriced or did not meet expectations in terms of quality.
Mixed Experiences
While many reviews were overwhelmingly positive, a few customers reported inconsistent experiences, particularly regarding meal preparation and service timing.
CC
Chad Cwold
6 days ago
4.0
Beautiful grounds and a cool restaurant. Old school Alabama high end restaurant. Dry aged steaks, oysters, beef tartare, Ceasar salad with sardines!! That salad was amazing. Good wine and liquor selection. Local joint visitors must go and enjoy. Bit of a drive, you won’t be disappointed.
WH
Walla Hatchee
Nov 7, 2025
5.0
“The restaurant is considered a staple in the community and the building has been a Magnolia Springs tradition for over 75 years, opening as Moore Bros Store in 1922.
Charles and Janie Houser purchased the building in 1998 and soon opened Jesse’s Restaurant in 1999 bringing back a vital piece of Magnolia Springs. Mr. Houser named the restaurant Jesse’s after Jesse King, the beloved shopkeeper of Moore’s Store who reportedly never missed a day of work for over 60 years.
We are always working to make Jesse’s better than we were yesterday. Owners, Steve and Angie Coltharp, purchased Jesse’s with a vision of being the most talked about steakhouse on the Gulf Coast. The Coltharps made a commitment to serve their guests the best quality products available and never stop changing for better.
We pride ourselves in serving unique cuts of dry and wet-aged steaks, bone-in cuts and fresh fish brought in daily.”
AC
Audra Challenger
Nov 7, 2025
3.0
We arrived at 2:30, so we ordered off the in-between menu. While our food was good, we ordered a dozen raw oysters from the menu and were disappointed to see that the restaurant did not serve top-raised, farmed oysters, as is typical at most restaurants of similar culinary caliber. When we told the server, he said they actually do have two farm-raised varieties. I’m not sure why these were not offered to us when we ordered oysters, nor why when we voiced our displeasure he did not do anything to fix his mistake.
On a pleasant note, the limoncello tiramisu was likely the best dessert I’ve had this year. The toasted pistachios were a beautiful touch.
CH
Cathy H
Nov 2, 2025
5.0
Every aspect of our dinner was just perfect. Each dish was prepared expertly, the staff was professional but with that extra touch of neighborliness I’ve come to really enjoy about this area. The meal was paced exactly right. And oh my goodness the cocktails! So unique and lovely. Special thanks to our server who patiently listened to my husband go on about his experience working in restaurants. 😁 The night could not have been better. We look forward to coming back to Jessie’s often.
SG
S Garcia
Nov 1, 2025
5.0
This was our 1st Time Dining, but surely not our last Visit to Jesse's Restaurant in Magnolia Springs. Such a Fabulous, Top of the Line Restaurant!!!! Our Waitress Kayda (not sure I am writing her name correctly) was Super Amazing, Explained Everything in Detail and even gave us some Suggestions, Bartender Sean as well was absolutely Amazing. All in one Employees in there were Friendly and open to Answer any Questions! Food is very Upscale and this Restaurant all Together brings an Excellent Vibe.
Frequently Asked Questions About Jesses Restaurant
Where is Jesses Restaurant located?
Jesses Restaurant is located at 14770 Oak St, Magnolia Springs, AL 36555, United States.
What type of cuisine does Jesses Restaurant serve?
Jesses Restaurant serves American cuisine and is a family style restaurant.
What is the best way to contact Jesses Restaurant?
You can contact Jesses Restaurant by phone at +1 251-965-3827 or by email at missy+modified@dwoodscpa.com.
What are the operating hours or timezone for Jesses Restaurant?
Jesses Restaurant operates in the America/Chicago timezone. Please call to inquire about specific operating hours.
Are there any family-friendly dining options at Jesses Restaurant?
Yes, Jesses Restaurant is categorized as a family style restaurant, making it suitable for dining with family.
What nearby places can be visited before or after dining at Jesses Restaurant?
You can visit the Magnolia Springs Public Library, Magnolia Art Springs Gallery, or take a relaxing walk along the Magnolia River or Magnolia River Oaks near Jesses Restaurant.
Are there any nearby religious organizations near Jesses Restaurant?
Yes, St Paul's Episcopal Chapel and Magnolia Springs Wesleyan church are located near Jesses Restaurant, providing options for spiritual visits.
Where can I find services like fire department or government offices near Jesses Restaurant?
The Magnolia Springs Volunteer Fire Department and Magnolia Springs Town Office are nearby, offering community and government services close to Jesses Restaurant.
Are there convenient stores or gas stations near Jesses Restaurant?
Yes, nearby convenient stores and gas stations include Kellams Corner, Minit Shop #54 - Pure, Shell, and Cougar Mini Mart, which are helpful for quick stops before or after dining.
Does Jesses Restaurant have any featured messages or promotions?
Jesses Restaurant encourages customers to call them today for more information or reservations.