At Papa Johns Pizza in Athens, AL, it’s our goal to always bring you Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. Whether it's our signature sauce, toppings, or fresh, original dough, we invest in our ingredients to ensure you have the best Athens pizza for any occasion. Call us for pizza delivery in Athens or stop by 916 US Highway 72 for carryout to order the best pizza in Athens, along with breadsticks, wings, and more!
Customers reported inconsistent food quality, with some praising the deliciousness while others complained about sparse toppings and overcooked pizzas.
Service Issues
Several reviews highlighted poor customer service experiences, including rude staff and unresolved order issues.
Delivery Experience
While many customers appreciated prompt and hot deliveries, there were complaints about delivery drivers asking for tips and issues with order accuracy.
Cleanliness Concerns
Some customers expressed concerns about cleanliness, particularly regarding food handling practices.
MM
Michael McNally
Feb 19, 2026
5.0
Quick, tasty, great hospitality
TM
Tim McGee
Feb 5, 2026
5.0
All my children love the pizza, sauce doesn't give us adults heartburn hardly like the others
LL
Lil-Lain
Jan 21, 2026
5.0
It was the best pizza I believe I have ate in a very long time.
AM
Alyssa martines
Dec 13, 2025
5.0
My kids love Papa John’s. This location is always on time with fresh and yummy pizza. No complaints from the kids. The only thing I would improve is sometimes the orders do not have what was asked for. Other than that this place is great! We also use the Papa dough which adds up with every purchase. It helps keep the price affordable for us.