Pizza Athena

Reviews

• AA

  Ally

  Jan 31, 2026
  2.0
  We want to love this place but this is the 2nd time we ordered via the website, went to pick up during the scheduled pick up and walk in and get told they just got the order online. This is after notification that the order was received and in progress. We ordered 45-50 minutes ago and now told to give her 10-15 more minutes. We could have gone elsewhere for an hour 20 wait.
• TK

  Tim K

  Jan 21, 2026
  5.0
  This is a carry out or delivery place. Everything i have had from them is pretty good. The pizza is my favorite in the valley so far though, and the wings are the best in AK. Big conisseur of wings in pizza, and I have never been disappointed by Pizza Athena. They do get busy, but the food is worth the wait. They are a small establishment, so be patient. And if they make a mistake, they will fix it.
• VF

  Vinny F

  Dec 26, 2025
  5.0
  We got 4 XL pizzas for $88 which I guess by today's standards is normal. The pepperoni pizza was really good! However, the cheese pizza left a lot to be desired. The cheese just did not melt well and was pretty much a slate of cheese with a little amount of sauce. Service was alright, the store is small and the shop does the best it can to get orders out. I would come back for the pepperoni pizza though for sure! Edit: Changed to five stars! We ordered again recently and had no issues with the food quality. The owner also addressed the issues we had before kindly and professionally. I commend her dedication to customer service and she's doing it right. Thank you Pizza Athena!
• JM

  Joshua McDaniel

  Dec 2, 2025
  5.0
  The pizza was probably the best I have had in a long while after living up and down the west coast. You can taste that they put thought and experience into thier food.
• AR

  Alternative home vet care Joanna Russell

  Nov 21, 2025
  5.0
  Best pizza in Alaska. Prices are a bit high. But eating out is costly! Love the food

Frequently Asked Questions About Pizza Athena