Papa Johns Pizza

Reviews

• YR

  Yelena Radyuk

  4 days ago
  1.0
  Sloppy and greedy. Ordered 2 large pizzas tonight for my family. Ordered online and prepaid. Upon pickup, I asked for 2 extra sauces, was told it was 2.50. I gave the guy 3 bucks and he walked away. I waited for a minute before I realized he was not coming back with change... lol. It was 50 cents, honestly no big deal. I noticed the quality seal stickers were not on properly, before I left the store (what is the point of sticking them on, if you dont do it properly?). I didnt mention anything as I left. But when I arrived home and we opened the boxes, there was a black hair in the box. That was the tipping point for me. I could've let the rest slide, but their obvious lack of quality control and care, and entitlement for tips is unacceptable. We wont be returning.
• LL

  Luke Lawson

  Nov 13, 2025
  1.0
  The worst pizza experience I've ever had at a Papa John's and in general. I've had a decent experience at other locations in the past but I won't be ordering Papa John's again. Get Royal Pizza if in the Seton area, much better quality control and great food. My last order/experience: Bone in wings: - Undercooked/wet skin, fatty, cheewy and they got the flavor wrong. Bone in wings: - Mostly breading, wrong flavor, not tossed in sauce, maybe 20% had drippings of sauce on them. Pizza: - Crust was hard and brittle it was cooked so much the crust was like eating a giant dried out cracker, no taste in the sauce, minimal sauce and cheese. Dips: - I was supposed to get multiple dips, only got 1 ranch dip.
• MH

  Manpreet Heer

  Nov 11, 2025
  1.0
  Worst pizza ever tasted this is not what papa john pizza should be tried from various different locations but this is the worst one the crushed pepper 1.30$ ridiculous with a pizza like this ruined my whole my appetite the base was super thin even with the regular topping falling apart no taste of pizza sauce. I guess we are not getting anything when we order thin crust improve the quality.
• KC

  Kim Cleland

  Nov 1, 2025
  1.0
  We ordered a pizza yesterday at 4 pm and it was supposed to be delivered by 5:30 pm. Based on the tracking it went into the oven around 8 pm and then wasn't delivered at all. I tried phoning dozens of times to cancel the order but no one answered all night. The order was finally cancelled on their end over night. No communication or updates on the status tracker about the delay/cancellation.
• KB

  KDB B

  Oct 31, 2025
  1.0
  I'd give 0 stars if I could. Pizza is 90 minutes late. Phone update says 90 more minutes. Call the line to cancel and they hang up without answering. We finally drove there and got our pizzas 2 hours late. Not delivered,and not the correct pizza. Sent in feedback as owner suggested. Over 3 weeks ago. No response.

Frequently Asked Questions About Papa Johns Pizza