Flagstar Bank in Hicksville, NY brings the strength of a diversified, regional bank to your community, grounded in building long term relationships with individuals, families, and businesses. We offer a full suite of consumer banking solutions, including everyday checking and high-yield savings accounts, CD’s, lending, and financial planning—all delivered with local expertise and a customer-first focus. Visit us to experience Flagstar’s commitment to excellence and personalized service.
This is not a safe or productive place for businesses.
I decided to try Flagstar because I’d been using a large national bank and I thought I would have a better, smarter service experience with people who care a bit more. During my time banking with them, I found this to be true. But only of the workers inside the bank.
I’m not sure what it is like to do personal banking with Flagstar, but if you use them as a business, they do not help you solve problems. They become the problem. My entire time with them, they were an adversary that harmed my business and drug me through months of delays, restrictions, “investigations”, and account closures.
-Their apps are slow, unsightly, and cumbersome to use
-Their upper management is very slow to respond
-Their back office is just as dark and destructive as any big national bank.
-Their back office is lacking in reasoning and analysis skills
Worst of all: This has been a bank hit bad by fraud and they react with the trauma of a wounded sparrow. Their “fraud management” team is a terrified, irrational panel of hammers desperately trying to make a nail of anything it finds, and with or without evidence they are eager to make a fraudster out of YOU- the customer.
I trusted them with my banking in June and they held, froze, investigated, and delayed my money until my accounts were closed in September. There was never any fraud, never any complaints, and never any accusations. Nevertheless, they held my money hostage the entire time under the enduring assumption that I was a criminal. Meanwhile, they made it impossible for me to cover operating expenses.
Perhaps if you are an individual who needs a place to deposit their paycheck and withdraw $20 from the ATM every so often, this may be a great place. The tellers were fantastic and welcoming and they remember who you are. I also loved the two bank managers I got to know during my time with them. Both of the managers were smart, capable, and able to understand by company and banking situation with minimal effort. Unfortunately, they are at the mercy of people above them in the company and below them in intellect and compassion.
If you are a business, I would seriously think twice about trusting this bank. They are not a “small, local bank that will look you in the eye and work alongside with you to thrive”. They are a hostile, destructive semi-national finance institution reeling in desperation and fear that you are lying in wait to defraud them.
CM
Clarymar ma
Nov 26, 2025
1.0
Very unprofessional experience at this branch. I came in to exchange bills,
something I’ve done here before in the past with signature & flagstar but was met with sarcasm and laughter from Michelle and Serena when I explained the situation. Instead of helping or showing basic professionalism, Michelle told me, “I guess you won’t be doing business here anymore.”
Customer service should be respectful and empathetic. She’s right, I won’t be returning to this branch again.
Please avoid Michelle at all cost .
BR
Brad Rhodes
Jan 30, 2025
5.0
Last night I called to find an answer to an account from 1985 , when I started the conversation I was upset not knowing what needed to be done, Flagstar aquired Wells Fargo in our area, so while I didn’t handle myself properly, the assistance I received was informative and I figured out what I needed to do . Appreciated the help
SM
Shakeida McCullough
Dec 6, 2024
1.0
Absolutely horrible company. Poor customer service. No follow through nor accountability. I wouldn't recommend banking with this company. If I could leave zero stars I would
MU
Milos Ubovic
Jul 3, 2024
1.0
We had an incredibly disappointing experience with David McGowan at Flagstar Financing and Leasing. His demeanor was not only unprofessional but also dismissive, giving the impression that deceiving customers was more important to him than providing real help. He mocked us openly and made it clear that he felt no need to engage respectfully. His dishonest practices and blatant disregard for professionalism were appalling. I urge everyone to steer clear of his services. Additionally, he consistently fails to answer phone calls.
Complete lack of professionalism and respect.
Avoid David McGowan at all costs.
What types of banking services does Flagstar Bank in Hicksville offer?
Flagstar Bank offers a full suite of consumer banking solutions including everyday checking, high-yield savings accounts, CDs, lending, and financial planning.
Where is Flagstar Bank located in Hicksville, NY?
It is located at 100 Duffy Avenue, Hicksville, NY 11801, US.
What are the operating hours for Flagstar Bank on weekdays?
The bank is open Monday through Thursday from 9:00 AM to 4:00 PM, and on Friday from 9:00 AM to 5:00 PM. It is closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
Is Flagstar Bank open on federal holidays?
Flagstar Bank is closed on major holidays such as November 11, November 27, and December 25.
Does Flagstar Bank provide mobile banking options?
Yes, Flagstar Bank offers mobile banking through its Flagstar Mobile app available for both Android and iOS devices.
What brands are associated with Flagstar Bank at the Duffy Avenue location?
The brands include AmTrust Bank, Atlantic Bank, Garden State Community Bank, New York Community Bank, Ohio Savings Bank, Queens County Savings Bank, Richmond County Savings Bank, Roosevelt Savings Bank, and Roslyn Savings Bank, all divisions of Flagstar Bank, N.A.
How can nearby Express Limo & Car Service help Flagstar Bank customers?
Customers can use Express Limo & Car Service for convenient airport shuttles or limo rides to and from the bank, making travel easier when visiting Flagstar Bank.
What financial advising services nearby might complement Flagstar Bank offerings?
Nearby services such as DRCG Deep Root Consulting Group and Alphyn Capital Management provide financial advising and investing services which can complement banking at Flagstar.
Are there any nearby health and home care services customers might find useful?
Yes, Day to Day Senior Care Consult and Services and Home Helpers Home Care of Farmingdale offer home health and personal care services near Flagstar Bank, useful for community members needing health support.
How can I contact Flagstar Bank at the Hicksville location?
You can contact the bank by calling their main phone number at +1 516-597-4721.
Brand Certified Facts from Flagstar Bank
This information is certified by Flagstar Bank and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified October 11, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: