South Shore YMCA | Staten Island

Reviews

• JM

  Jamie M

  Oct 20, 2025
  1.0
  While I appreciate that the facility strives to accommodate all age groups, several issues have made it increasingly difficult for paying members to enjoy their workouts. Many senior members enrolled through programs such as SilverSneakers and AARP frequently occupy large areas of the gym, particularly the track and common workout spaces, in a way that disrupts other members’ ability to train effectively. For example, the walking track often becomes a place for social gatherings, making it nearly impossible for those wishing to run or exercise at a faster pace to do so safely. Additionally, the temperature balance throughout the facility has become inconsistent—certain rooms are uncomfortably warm while others are overly cold, seemingly adjusted back and forth based on continuous complaints. This inconsistency affects the comfort and performance of all members. Lastly, parking availability has become a challenge due to early hours of use by specific groups, leaving limited space for full-paying members during regular morning and midday times. Considering that members enrolled through external senior fitness programs often have subsidized memberships, I strongly encourage management to review pricing and accessibility policies to ensure fairness and value for those paying full membership rates. I truly value the gym and would like to continue my membership, but I hope these concerns can be addressed to create a more balanced and equitable experience for everyone.
• MB

  milna baez

  Sep 4, 2025
  5.0
  I love the ymca, the trainers are always very nice and helpful, if anyone need any assistance I recommend Laura, such a great person to talk to and so helpful and thorough, I’m sure the others are too, the place, the locker room and bathrooms are always clean. The people at the front desk by the entrance are also very nice and friendly, I have not tried other programs or classes just the gym but hopefully I will in the near future, have a blessed day everyone everyday, glad to be part of the YMCA. ❤️👍👏
• SZ

  Sien Zhao

  Jul 27, 2025
  1.0
  Some old people took the lane as their own and are harrassing kids from swimming in it. Every Single Time my kids swim, one or two old people came saying we have to leave that it's Y's policy blablabla, we have to get help from staff to let them know we can swim here, and guess what they gave my kids eyeballs, so disgusting! The experience is so bad that it feels they occupied this place and trying to chase away others so they can enjoy it as their own backyard! We might leave for this nonsense.
• MC

  Michael Ciccone

  Jul 17, 2025
  1.0
  Young adult men loitering in rear parking lot in corner. Black BMW race car one guy was smoking marijuana while talking with someone with similar car. I was approaching my vehicle after finishing up my workout. Not the first time people loitering in same rear parking lot. Smelling second hand marijuana smoke is unhealthy..I don't feel safe parking in the rear parking lot .
• GL

  Gianni Latorre

  Jul 8, 2025
  1.0
  Please update your cancellation process. It's not 1990 anymore. I was able to do the membership in person and asked them that it would be just for 1 month because we would leave after 4 weeks. They told me they couldn't accept a cancellation on the same day o_O and that I had to do it at least the day after. I tried to do it online the day after, but that was not an option, sadly. When I was able to go there in person, I filled out the cancellation form, but it was too late at that point. I will now have to pay 1 full month for my daughter's membership, without using a day of it, because we'll be on vacation for 2 months. You guys just lost 3 members at once.

Frequently Asked Questions About South Shore YMCA | Staten Island