Many customers praised the professionalism and responsiveness of Jaime and his crew throughout the roofing process.
Quality of Work
The quality of the roofing work was frequently highlighted, with numerous reviews noting excellent craftsmanship and thorough cleanup after the job.
Customer Service
While most reviews reflected positive experiences with customer service, one review pointed out a significant negative experience with phone etiquette.
Competitive Pricing
Customers consistently mentioned that All Star Roofing offered competitive pricing compared to other estimates they received.
MS
Molly Shier
Feb 4, 2026
5.0
Jamie and his team did an outstanding job replacing my roof this past fall. From start to finish, they were incredibly easy to work with. Professional, responsive, and genuinely committed to doing the job right. The pricing was very reasonable, the crew worked efficiently and left everything clean when they were done. I would recommend All Star Roofing to anyone looking for a reliable, trustworthy roofing company.
RR
raymond
Dec 19, 2025
1.0
Called for an estimate. Got hung up on faster than a bad painting.
The man who answered the phone sounded like I personally tore off his roof, stole his ladder, and blamed him for the weather. No greeting—just immediate attitude shingles, layered thick.
I asked a simple question. A roof-level question. Nothing crazy. Nothing illegal. Nothing that required NASA clearance.
Apparently that was my first mistake.
Every response came with: • sighs heavier than wet plywood
• interruptions sharper than roofing nails
• and a tone so condescending it needed its own safety harness
Mid-sentence—MID. SENTENCE.—
CLICK.
Hung up on.
No warning.
No goodbye.
No mercy.
I’ve had scam callers show more commitment to a conversation.
Customer service here is like a leaky roof: loud, stressful, and clearly not being maintained. Professionalism must’ve blown off in the last storm because it was nowhere to be found.
Roofing expertise? Unconfirmed.
Phone etiquette? Fell through the ceiling.
Communication skills? Needs a full tear-off and replacement.
Vibes? Straight hail damage.
Calling All Star Roofing and Repair felt less like contacting a business and more like accidentally calling a guy who hates roofs, phones, people, and joy.
Five stars for confidence.
Zero stars for not hanging up politely.
Would recommend only if you enjoy being: • cut off
• talked over
• emotionally reroofed
• and abruptly disconnected like a bad Wi-Fi signal
All Star Roofing and Repair:
They don’t raise the roof —
they raise your blood pressure. ⭐
JK
Jackie Kowalski
Nov 22, 2025
5.0
All star did my roof friday. They were done all in one day. Done by 430 as well. Jaime was very nice and helpful. Also was very reasonable out of the 3 other estimates I received. Called them on the 10th and they came out on the 21st.
LL
LISA
Oct 28, 2025
5.0
We had our roof, gutters, downspouts and gutter guards installed by All Star Roofing. We are so thrilled with the quality job they did, all within the timeline that was promised! Jaime was honest and had great communication skills. The price was just as he quoted. All Star Roofing does an awesome job and I highly recommend them!
SK
Scott Kalous
Sep 30, 2025
5.0
A pleasure to do business with. Good price and great clean up after the job. Would use them again.
Frequently Asked Questions About All Star Roofing LLC
What services does All Star Roofing LLC provide?
All Star Roofing LLC offers complete roof replacement, roof repairs, and gutter services in Green Bay, WI.
Where is All Star Roofing LLC located?
All Star Roofing LLC is located at 1161 S Taylor St, Green Bay, WI 54304, US.
What are the business hours for All Star Roofing LLC?
The business is open Monday through Saturday from 7:00 AM to 7:00 PM and is closed on Sundays.
Does All Star Roofing LLC offer same-day services?
Yes, All Star Roofing LLC provides same-day services.
What languages are spoken at All Star Roofing LLC?
All Star Roofing LLC staff communicate in both English and Spanish.
What payment methods are accepted at All Star Roofing LLC?
All Star Roofing LLC accepts payment by cash and check.
How can I contact All Star Roofing LLC?
You can reach them by phone at +1 920-928-9004 or +1 920-530-5672, or email at allstarroofingwi@gmail.com.
What nearby food options are available around All Star Roofing LLC?
Nearby dining options include Popeyes® Louisiana Kitchen for Cajun-style fast food, Pizza Hut for pizza, and Burger House 41 for burgers, making it convenient for customers coming for a consultation or service.
Are there any entertainment or event planning services near All Star Roofing LLC?
Yes, Batterham Entertainment and Elite Music Service are nearby, offering event planning and entertainment which might be of interest to customers visiting the area.
What local landmarks or community places are near All Star Roofing LLC?
Nearby establishments include The Granite Co (a building supply store), Green Bay West KinderCare (preschool), and Tilleman Bridge (bridge and pub), providing useful points of reference for finding All Star Roofing LLC and places to visit after appointments.
Brand Certified Facts from All Star Roofing LLC
All Star Roofing LLC partners directly with Yext to publish this data from the brand's official system of record. Learn more about our data sources
Certified March 01, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: