TL;DR: What can I say? There is a reason Gator Garage Doors has a 5 star rating on Google - they are efficient, honest, courteous, and good at what they do. I'm not really sure you can get much more than this out of a company to fix your garage door issues. If you have a Garage Door issue - call these guys asap.
Because I like to leave a thorough review, here are the details!
Cost: I honestly did not price compare, these are the first guys I called, and because the technician that came out (Aaron Terry) was such a pro at everything I had no need to get another quote from anyone else. I'd think the price for what I got was reasonable, I had an old Genie model (9 years old) with one spring, both were busted. I had them both replaced, all new stuff, new remotes and keypads, etc. I will also state, I was presented with 5 different quotes, all of which would have fixed the issue, so I had a low-end and a high-end to choose from. Good to have options that fit your budget.
Service: Aaron was the first service technician in my life that called me ahead of time, told me when he was going to arrive, said he was probably going to stop at a gas station and asked if I wanted anything to drink, or a coffee... WHAT?! Sure, I've had technicians call ahead, let me know when they'll be there, all that... but how do you stand out? Ask the client IF THEY WANT SOMETHING ON THEIR WAY?! I had not even had them inspect anything, commit to paying for anything, etc.. Small thing, big impact honestly. When Aaron got here, he was just as professional and courteous - can't get any better than Aaron really.
Efficiency: Scheduling only took a few minutes, and they were able to get us in the next day - I don't necessarily know if this is indicative of their staffing, seasonality, etc.. so maybe don't expect that always, but 1 day for a non-emergency is pretty dang good (I say non-emergency because we didn't have a car or anything else important "stuck" in the garage). From the time Aaron got here, to the time he completed the job and left, it was maybe 3-4 hours? To diagnose the issue, explain it, go through quote's and scenarios and answer questions, THEN also fix it and install the new stuff - I was impressed.