I was originally going to leave a one-star review, but I’m giving Leonard’s a second star because the service I received from them in the past was generally pretty good. Unfortunately, my experience today was completely different.
About 2.5 years and only 7,000 miles ago, Leonard’s replaced my windshield washer pump because it wasn’t working. My car was already disassembled for a condenser replacement at the time, so it was an inexpensive repair and I figured it made sense to have them replace it while they were in there.
That replacement pump failed about three months ago, and I finally brought the car back in. Before I even handed over the key, I was told there would be a $160 diagnostic fee. I actually appreciated them being upfront about that.
I wasn’t expecting a free replacement part after 2.5 years. I understand warranties expire. What I wasn’t expecting was a quote of more than $700 to replace the washer pump they installed less than 7,000 miles ago. If I remember correctly, roughly $650 of the quote was for the pump and labor, plus a grommet and some miscellaneous items.
An OEM washer pump for this car is about $26. Even if you mark that up substantially—call it $100—I have a hard time understanding the remaining cost. More importantly, this is a part Leonard’s installed brand new less than 7,000 miles ago. I work from home and barely drive this car, and I rarely even use the windshield washers. I’ve probably activated that pump fewer than 100 times since it was installed. There was apparently no consideration whatsoever given to the fact that their replacement failed after such little use and mileage.
What bothered me even more were some of the additional recommended services. One was a cabin air filter replacement. I personally replaced that filter only a couple of months ago, which makes me seriously question whether anyone actually inspected it before recommending that I pay to replace it again.
Then there was a recommendation for a transmission fluid service. Leonard’s themselves performed the transmission service on this same car less than 10,000 miles ago.
Those recommendations are what turned an expensive repair estimate into a loss of confidence for me. When I’m being advised to replace something I recently replaced myself and service a transmission that this same shop serviced less than 10,000 miles ago, I have to question how carefully these recommendations are being made.
And as for the washer pump, why would I spend another $700+ replacing a part that Leonard’s installed only 7,000 miles ago when there was apparently no consideration given to its unusually short service life? What confidence would I have that I won’t be right back in the same situation?
I’ve had good experiences with Leonard’s in the past, which is why this visit was so disappointing. I trusted this shop. After today, that trust has been seriously damaged.