JM
Justin Maslowski
Aug 19, 2026
I rented a Chrysler Pacifica with 42,000 miles from your Buffalo Niagara International Airport location from July 23–27. At pickup, the agent handed me the keys without telling me which vehicle was mine. When I asked which minivan was ours, he told me to go try them and if one started, that was my car. The vehicle I was eventually able to identify was dirty and had visible cosmetic damage — scratches and a large dent in the rear door. I documented the condition of the vehicle with time/date/location photo and video evidence.
When I returned the vehicle, I raised these issues with the return agent, who reviewed the vehicle, acknowledged its condition, and adjusted my bill accordingly. I appreciated her handling of the situation.
However, about a week later, I received a formal notice from your Damage Recovery Unit claiming I was responsible for damage to the vehicle and that I would be billed for it — despite having video documentation, taken at pickup, showing the damage was already present. I had to submit a formal written dispute, including an incident report, to resolve this. I was also told on multiple occasions that someone from the Damage Recovery Unit would call me back, and those calls never came; I ultimately had to follow up repeatedly on my own to get this closed. You sent written confirmation on August 14, 2026 that the claim was closed and I would not be charged.
I've been a National Emerald Club member since 2018 and have rented exclusively with National for the past seven-plus years. This Buffalo experience is the first time that's fallen short I'm sharing this feedback not to relitigate the claim, which is now resolved, but because I spent a significant amount of time and had a fair amount of stress dealing with a claim that should never have been filed in the first place, on top of a pickup experience that was unprofessional from the start.