Brand Certified
Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle
4.4(111 reviews)
Certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle • Oct 04, 2026
Business Details
421 New York Avenue, New Castle, IN
47362, United States
Certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle • Oct 04, 2026
(765) 529-5103
Certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle • Oct 04, 2026
https://www.rileyandsons.com/locations/421-new-york-ave-new-castle-indiana-47362
Certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle • Oct 04, 2026
About
Certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle • Oct 04, 2026
Auto Body ShopAuto Repair ShopAuto Dent Removal ServiceAuto Body RepairAuto MaintenanceAuto Glass Shop
Riley and Sons Collision is a a family owned collision repair business, serving the East Central Indiana community since 1957. Our technicians are trained in the latest vehicle technology and our facilities are equipped with state-of-the-art equipment. All of our shops are ICAR Gold Class Certified. ICAR Gold Class recognition is the highest role-relevant achievement recognized by the collision repair industry. Less than 10% of collision repair shops in the United States have achieved this milestone. We believe in investing in our team members and setting higher standards of repair for our customers.
Location
Certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle • Oct 04, 2026
Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle
421 New York Avenue, New Castle, IN
47362, United States
Hours
Certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle • Oct 04, 2026
Monday8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Tuesday8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Wednesday8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Thursday8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Friday8:00 AM - 5:00 PM
SaturdayClosed
SundayClosed
10/12/2026Closed
11/11/2026Closed
11/26/20268:00 AM - 5:00 PM
12/25/20268:00 AM - 5:00 PM
1/1/20278:00 AM - 5:00 PM
Products & Services
1 list · 10 items
Explore offerings from Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle on 421 New York Avenue in New Castle, with popular general services available at this location.
Reviews
4.4
111 reviews
5 stars
85
4 stars
9
3 stars
3
2 stars
3
1 star
11
- JTjoshua thompsonAug 30, 20262.0I have used this shop 3 times now . First time was amazing customer service and work . 2nd time not so much . 'I gave Riley and Sons another chance because I was told they'd make a good deal for me. Unfortunately, that didn't happen after the manager and regional who promised it was no longer there. The paint job previously wasn't to the quality expected, and they had the car for an extra week. I was told the rental car cost would be covered, but I was pursued for the bill by the rental company. Based on those experiences, I expected the company to follow through on what was promised, but that didn't happen. I hope they can improve communication and stand by their commitments to customers I will say the shop manager who is there now did try to help me but the regional austin didn't allow him to make right on the promise the previous manager and regional gave me. This will be my last time using their services I did reach out to Austin to see if he would make things right and he wasn't interested in doing that.
- JCJaime ColvinJun 4, 20265.0Great customer service team. Quick pickup they kept me updated and was ready when they said !!! Nice people
- ASamber spurginJul 31, 20255.0Car looks like new and was reasonably priced would definitely use again.
- JWJeannine WintersAug 20, 20175.0They did a great job fixing our window. They even gave my husband a ride to work when he dropped off the van.
Frequently Asked Questions About Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle
My car might not be safe to drive, what should I do?
Never drive a vehicle that may be unsafe. Your safety is worth much more than the cost of a tow, and most insurance policies have coverage for towing. Call Riley & Sons and we will have your vehicle towed to our safe and secure lot.
You have the right to choose a repair shop to fix your vehicle so if you want Riley & Sons to repair your vehicle, you have the right to choose us.
Basically, get the CLAIM NUMBER from your insurance company and Riley & Sons will be able to start the process and get you scheduled to repair your vehicle. If you need help getting the CLAIM NUMBER we can help you with that too. It’s that easy and that is our goal to provide excellent customer service from the start to the finish.
I've just had an accident. What should I do first?
We know and understand how frustrating an accident can be. We are experts in not only repairing your vehicle, but assisting with the claims process as well. Please contact us immediately to assist in arranging a tow truck if needed or to assist you with the claims process. We work with all insurance carriers and will ensure your vehicle will be repaired properly and timely.
Do I need an appointment for a collision repair or auto painting estimate?
In order to properly estimate your repair, we ask that you schedule an appointment either online or by giving us a call.
Are the collision repair and auto painting estimates free and without obligation?
Absolutely. At Riley & Sons, we strongly believe that collision repair estimates should be free and on your schedule. If you're in need of auto body repair, auto painting or other collision center services in the Lafayette area, you can trust the team at Riley & Sons to offer you an accurate estimate. You don't deserve the runaround, and we promise not to ever do that to any of our customers. All of our estimates are 100% free, and we do everything we can to accommodate your schedule and needs in order to make the entire vehicle repair process as painless as possible.
What if my vehicle is not safe to drive to your facility for a collision repair estimate?
Never drive an unsafe vehicle in need of collision repair. If your car is too damaged to safely drive to our convenient Lafayette, Indiana auto body shop, we will gladly arrange for safe towing of your vehicle to our state of the art collision repair facility.
Can I choose what types of parts are used on my vehicle when repaired?
You, as the vehicle owner, may always choose the type of parts to be used on your vehicle. In Indiana, if your vehicle is 5 years or newer and you are going through your own insurance company, it is required by law to allow you to choose the type of parts you would like used in your repairs. This law covers any metal or plastic part that generally constitutes the exterior of the vehicle.
Do I need to get three estimates for the insurance company that is paying for the collision repairs?
No, the law does not require that you receive multiple estimates before choosing a body shop to make your collision repairs. It's nice to know that there is no law that requires you get more than one collision center estimate or appraisal on your damaged vehicle. Of course, we encourage you to get as many estimates as you'd like in order to help you make an informed decision about your vehicle's collision repair. In the end, of course, cheap collision repair is not your goal, though with our efficient collision center, we can complete your paint and body repairs in a cost-effective manner without compromising quality or safety.
What can you do to help me get the attention of the responsible insurance company?
Top collision centers can help you communicate better with insurance companies, and because we work so closely with so many Lafayette-area insurance companies, we may even be able to help you cut through the red tape to guarantee a more efficient, seamless collision repair process. We are experts at helping our customers navigate the entire claims process.
Can my insurance adjuster come to Riley & Sons to inspect my vehicle?
Yes, your insurance company can inspect your damaged vehicle at our location. Because we work closely with every major insurance company in Indiana, your insurance adjuster can come to our location to inspect your vehicle. While we understand that many insurance companies would like you to visit their claims facilities with your damaged car, we also know that this is not always convenient or even possible for our customers, so we make it convenient for your insurance adjuster to come visit us to inspect your vehicle before any collision repairs are made.
Why are there so many discrepancies in different collision repair estimates?
Unfortunately, not all vehicle repair estimates are apples-to-apples. Differences in collision repair estimates are actually quite common because of a number of factors in the body shop industry. Here are just a few of the most common reasons why one estimate may be significantly lower than another:A collision repair estimate may not include all necessary work or may quote substandard replacement parts or paints.Not all Lafayette body shops or Indy collision repair centers are I-CAR or ASE certified. Not all Indianapolis body shops are capable of unibody repair. Advanced equipment and training costs more - but the results can be spectacular and the differences quite noticeable.Your collision repairs may not include a warranty from a reputable company that protects you for as long as you own your vehicle.
Why has Riley & Sons invested so much in a state-of-the-art facility, while most body shops are just large, dirty garages?
Your vehicle is too large of an investment to leave its repair to chance. Because your car, truck, SUV, minivan or crossover is probably the second largest investment you've made, it is critical that any auto painting or auto body repair preserve its value and especially your safety. At Riley & Sons we are always 100% committed to your satisfaction and safety. We want to be the best collision repair center and that requires having the correct equipment that ensures industry standards are maintained.
Should I plan for replacement transportation in advance?
It depends, but it is a good idea. Because the average vehicle collision repair and auto painting can take two weeks, it is important to plan in advance for your replacement vehicle needs. At Prime Body and Paint, we have an on-site Enterprise Rent-A-Car office that can quickly and easily arrange for replacement transportation with or without an appointment. Of course, when you schedule your repairs, let us know, and we will have a rental car waiting for you. Remember to let your insurance company know that you will be needing a rental, if they are handling the charges.
Can I choose where to take my damaged vehicle for collision repair?
Yes, as the vehicle owner, you have the right to have collision repairs performed on your vehicle anywhere you would like. Insurance companies cannot make you take your vehicle to a body shop that you do not wish to use. This is your right as a consumer. For example, insurance companies cannot require you to use their "preferred" body shop for your collision repair and auto painting needs - even when that body shop is Riley & Sons. And while we are often recommended by many insurance companies for our quality collision repair, as the consumer you have the final say in who you will trust with your vehicle repair needs.
Do I have to repair my vehicle where the insurance company suggests?
You have the legal right to choose the shop of your choice to repair your vehicle. Riley & Sons works directly with all insurance companies, and possess the training and state of the art equipment to safely and efficiently repair even the most sophisticated vehicles.
I received an estimate from the insurance company what should I do?
Just bring the estimate to Riley & Sons. We honor all insurance estimates, regardless of amount. We will work directly with the insurance company to document all damages and restore your vehicle to pre-accident condition. Remember, estimates are just starting points, and changes to them can be made once the vehicle is disassembled and all related damages can be seen.
Do I need more than one estimate?
No. There is no law requiring you to get more than one estimate. You only need one estimate from the place you want your vehicle repaired. If the insurance company wants a second estimate, they can send their own appraiser to look at the vehicle. Then Riley & Sons will honor the insurance company’s estimate.
What types of collision repair services does Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle offer?
They offer full collision repair services including dent repair, fender repair & replacement, frame straightening, hail damage repair, painting, scratch repair, wheel repair & alignment, and bumper repair & replacement.
Do I need to make an appointment for a collision repair or auto painting estimate?
Yes, you should schedule an appointment either online or by phone to get a proper estimate for your collision repair or auto painting.
Are collision repair and auto painting estimates free and without obligation?
Yes, all collision repair estimates at Riley & Sons are 100% free and without obligation to ensure a pain-free repair process.
What should I do if my vehicle is not safe to drive to your facility?
Do not drive an unsafe vehicle. Riley & Sons will arrange safe towing of your vehicle to their state-of-the-art collision repair facility.
Can I choose what types of parts are used on my vehicle when repaired at Riley & Sons?
Yes, as the vehicle owner, you have the right to choose the type of parts used in your repair, especially for vehicles 5 years or newer.
Does Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle offer pickup and delivery services?
They offer curbside pickup but do not provide delivery services.
What payment options are accepted at Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle?
They accept American Express, Cash, Check, MasterCard, and Visa for payment.
Where is Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle located and what are their hours?
They are located at 421 New York Avenue, New Castle, IN 47362 and are open Monday to Friday from 8:00 AM to 5:00 PM. They are closed on weekends and certain holidays.
What nearby places can customers visit before or after their collision repair at Riley & Sons?
Customers can visit Enterprise Rent-A-Car nearby for rental vehicles, Gibson Arena for events, or Walmart for shopping before or after their visit to Riley & Sons.
How can nearby Enterprise Rent-A-Car assist customers of Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle?
Enterprise Rent-A-Car nearby can provide replacement transportation quickly and easily for customers needing a rental car during their vehicle's repair.
Brand Certified Facts from Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle
This information is certified by Riley & Sons Collision of New Castle and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified October 04, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
- Address
- Categories
- Geo coordinates
- Legal business name
- Hours of operation
- Phone number
- Official website