Reynolds Body Shop has proudly served our community with expert auto collision repair services since 1984. From minor dents and dings to major collision damage, our experienced technicians are equipped to handle all your collision repair needs with precision and care. As your trusted neighborhood collision repair experts, we’re committed to making the entire process easy and stress-free from start to finish. We work with all insurance companies directly to ensure a smooth, hassle-free experience and get you safely back on the road. We’re proud to be a premier choice for collision repair conveniently located in Indianapolis, IN. At Reynolds Body Shop, we’re dedicated to getting you back to GO.
from start to finish, Reynold’s provided white glove service. the front desk staff was very warm and welcoming and the technician was so thorough and helpful in explaining to me all the steps involved in my repair. getting your car repaired is never a fun thing but Reynold’s made it a very pleasant experience. i was so impressed that i could drop my car off, get a quick but thorough explainer and as soon as we were done, Enterprise was waiting to take me to pick up a rental. it was masterful hospitality that more businesses could learn from. you all should teach a class!
JR
Jeanette Rodriguez
Aug 20, 2026
5.0
I love it here. Staff here is great and understanding. I won't go anywhere else!
SM
Senaia Mac
Aug 19, 2026
1.0
I had an extremely frustrating experience with this company and would not recommend them based on how my situation was handled.
My car sat for **three months without being worked on**. Part of the reason for the delay was that the company was not responding to my insurance company’s requests to get the repairs moving. Then, once things finally progressed, they didn’t have the necessary parts to fix my car.
My interactions with **Melinda** were especially disappointing. I found her to be extremely unprofessional and unhelpful. I felt like she spoke down to me throughout the process, as if I had no understanding of what was going on.
What made things even worse was how the pickup and storage situation was handled. I received a text saying my car was done and that they would call when it was available for pickup. I called **30 minutes after receiving the text**, only to be given an excuse and told they would call me back when the car was actually ready. I waited **three days** without receiving a call or any follow-up, despite trying to reach them multiple times. During those three days, my insurance company was charged approximately **$3,000 in storage fees**.
The entire experience made me feel like the priority was collecting money rather than providing good customer service or helping get my car back to me. Almost everyone I dealt with acted like helping me was an inconvenience, with the exception of **Chris** (I believe that was his name), who was the one person who seemed genuinely helpful and respectful.
Three months without my car, poor communication, unnecessary delays, and thousands of dollars in storage fees made this a terrible experience. I hope management takes a serious look at how customers and insurance claims are being handled because this should not be the experience anyone has when they are already dealing with the stress of having their car damaged.
DB
Dale Brooks
Aug 7, 2026
1.0
Bad service, bad timing, bad management
CM
Camille Mitchell
Aug 6, 2026
5.0
James Casey gets me together every single time!! Zero hassles!! 100% customer service!! I give them a 11 out of 10!!!!!!
Frequently Asked Questions About Reynolds Body Shop
What services does Reynolds Body Shop offer?
Reynolds Body Shop offers collision repair, diagnostics and calibrations, estimate & claim guidance, frame/unibody repair, glass replacement, mechanical repairs, non-collision damage repair, paint services, and paintless dent repair.
Where is Reynolds Body Shop located?
Reynolds Body Shop is located at 4325 West Washington Street, Indianapolis, IN 46241-0821.
What are the operating hours of Reynolds Body Shop?
The shop is open Monday through Friday from 7:30 AM to 5:00 PM and closed on Saturdays and Sundays.
Does Reynolds Body Shop work with insurance companies?
Yes, they work directly with all insurance companies to ensure a smooth, hassle-free collision repair experience.
What payment options are accepted at Reynolds Body Shop?
They accept American Express, Android Pay, Apple Pay, Cash, Discover, MasterCard, Samsung Pay, and Visa.
Is Reynolds Body Shop wheelchair accessible?
Yes, the shop has wheelchair accessible entrances, parking, and restrooms.
Does Reynolds Body Shop provide services in languages other than English?
Yes, they provide services in English and Spanish.
Are there any nearby car dealerships where I can find a vehicle after service?
Yes, nearby car dealerships include Curtis Motor Sales, D&H Auto Sales, Master Cars, Indy Rides, Merliot Auto Sales, and Autos La Piedad, which might be convenient if you are considering purchasing a vehicle.
What nearby places can I visit for food or treats before or after my appointment?
You can visit Jireh Desserts, a bakery and Mexican restaurant nearby, for a delicious meal or dessert.
Is there a nearby park where I can relax while my car is being repaired?
Yes, Christina Oaks Park is close by, where you can enjoy outdoor activities and relax during your wait.
Brand Certified Facts from Reynolds Body Shop
This information is certified by Reynolds Body Shop and published from the brand's official system of record. Data is distributed through an enterprise-grade knowledge management platform. Learn more about our data sources
Certified August 30, 2026Yext Knowledge Graph
Address
Categories
Geo coordinates
Legal business name
Hours of operation
Phone number
Official website
Syndication Network
Approved business data is pushed to 100+ publishers, including: