This was our first time renting a car from Alamo. We picked up a car from this location and unfortunately, the Wagoneer we chose had a constant, weird vibration feel if we went over 65mph. Apparently, according to Google, people have complained about the same thing with this particular type of car.
We ended up going back to Alamo the next day (same location) to request a switch and that was taken care immediately and efficiently. Not only that, at the end of the trip when we ended up returning the vehicle, Justin gave us some money back for thr inconvenience. That was extremely kind and helpful of him.
The staff here were all kind, professional, and friendly. I highly recommend utilizing Alamo's services for your rental car needs as the staff here know how to treat customers! Also, there were tons of cars and options to choose from!
I will definitely be using their services in the future again!
I want to share our experience and demand a full investigation into what has been an unacceptable and deeply disruptive rental car experience.
We picked up a hybrid Jeep Wrangler at the Fort Lauderdale airport on Thursday, April 23 and began our drive to Key West. Approximately 10 miles outside of Key West, a dump truck traveling North on US 1 [in the opposite direction] kicked up or a rock flew out of the bed of the truck, struck the upper right portion of our windshield, causing a significant crack. I immediately contacted roadside assistance and arranged for a replacement vehicle at the Key West airport.
After stopping briefly at our hotel to check in and drop off luggage, we returned to the vehicle only to find it would not start due to a dead battery. Upon opening the hood, we discovered the battery cover had already been removed, strongly suggesting this was a known, ongoing issue that had not been addressed prior to renting the vehicle. After unsuccessful attempts by valet staff to jump-start the car, I was forced to arrange a tow.
We then paid out of pocket for an Uber to the Key West airport, where we waited an additional 45 minutes for a replacement vehicle. Meanwhile, the towing process became chaotic and uncoordinated, multiple tow companies were dispatched, resulting in repeated calls and confusion. The vehicle was eventually removed without any notification or receipt, and additional tow operators continued to arrive the following day, frustrated and unaware the job had already been completed.
The replacement vehicle presented immediate concerns. From the moment we started it, the engine fan ran excessively loud, even while idling, indicating a potential mechanical issue. Those concerns proved valid. Two days later, while driving north and crossing the Seven Mile Bridge, the vehicle displayed an overheating warning. This created a genuinely dangerous and terrifying situation, with the risk of being stranded on a narrow bridge span. We were forced to pull over and wait for the vehicle to cool.
When we contacted roadside assistance during this critical moment, we were told the only solution was to dispatch a tow truck from Miami, three hours away and then ride back with it to pick up a replacement vehicle. That meant over 10 hours of unnecessary waiting and insane travel, which was completely unreasonable. When we pushed back and asked for an alternative, the agent demanded an immediate decision and then hung up on us. With no viable support, we made the decision to cautiously proceed off the bridge to our hotel in Big Pine Key. Upon arrival, we found ourselves effectively stranded, no food delivery, no rideshare availability, and no immediate assistance options.
Ultimately a third replacement vehicle, towed all the way from Miami, did not arrive until approximately 10:00pm last night.
The third vehicle was finally reliable, allowing us to continue our vacation without further disruption from poorly maintained and faulty cars. We returned that third vehicle in Fort Lauderdale on Thursday, April 29, and flew back to New York.
Unbelievably, the very next day after the vehicle had already been returned, I was contacted by roadside assistance attempting to tow it. How does that even happen?
In just four days in the Keys, we went through three rental cars. Completely unacceptable.