Tire Choice Auto Service Centers

4.7
405 reviews

About

Tire Shop
Visit Tire Choice Auto Service Centers for dealer-quality auto maintenance and repair services. We provide comprehensive automotive care, including vehicle maintenance, inspections, installations, repairs, roadside assistance, and towing services. Our expert technicians also offer check engine services. We specialize in tire changes with top-quality brands like Goodyear, Cooper, Nexen, Kumho, and Ironman.

Location

Tire Choice Auto Service Centers
1575 Mentor Avenue, Painesville, OH
44077, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.7
405 reviews
5 stars
364
4 stars
15
3 stars
2
2 stars
3
1 star
21

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Many customers praised the staff for being friendly, helpful, and accommodating, particularly highlighting individuals like Matt and Alicia for their exceptional service.

Efficiency

Numerous reviews noted the quick service and ability to handle repairs promptly, often getting customers in and out in a timely manner.

Mixed Experiences

While many customers had positive experiences, some reported issues with service quality and professionalism, indicating inconsistency in customer experiences.

Value for Money

Several customers mentioned fair pricing and good value for services rendered, although some felt certain services were overpriced.

Attention to Detail

Feedback indicated that while some staff were thorough and attentive, there were instances where details were overlooked, leading to customer dissatisfaction.
  • AD
    Alessio DiFranco
    Jan 5, 2026
    5.0
    The team took care of us at the end of the shift ensuring we had a tire swapped out to get home.
  • AP
    Alexa pircio
    Jan 2, 2026
    5.0
    I stopped here to get my tire looked at because it had been continuously leaking. The gentleman discovered someone punctured my tire that resulted in an air leak. I knew someone did something but I wasn’t sure how much damage was done and I appreciate them taking the time to look at it. I was unable to make an appointment, this was the first location that I was able to get to the quickest. He was great help and very knowledgeable. Thanks again
  • JH
    James Hall
    Dec 25, 2025
    5.0
    I’ve been dealing with Matt and his team at Tire Choice for about three years now, and I can honestly say they are the absolute best. Matt is extremely personable, knowledgeable, and most importantly—HONEST. That’s hard to find these days, and it’s why I trust him with all of my vehicles. Just this month alone, I’ve taken five of my cars here for general maintenance. Every time, the service is consistent, transparent, and professional. They never try to upsell unnecessary repairs and they always explain exactly what’s going on in a way that makes sense. As long as Matt is managing this location, I won’t go anywhere else for maintenance, minor repairs, or tire service. Highly recommend!
  • ZM
    Zanet Muhammad
    Dec 19, 2025
    1.0
    Went to get air in my tires. Asked in advance if they had any availability. The lady said yes. I tried booking an appointment she said to just come in they had the availability. I drive here in a snow storm to get the air and they say they are behind it’s going to be a long wait. Why not say that over the phone and schedule me a time when you’re available. Now I have to drive somewhere else with barely any air in my back tires. Complete waste of time. Wouldn’t not recommended if your are looking for good customer service.
  • MM
    Matthew McElwain
    Dec 3, 2025
    1.0
    This has my first time doing an oil change here. Given that I had gone to take 5 and Vavoline for years I expected that the service would have been roughly the same. Seems like all they do is change the oil and filter and that’s it. For 80.00 plus tax I expected more. I had to ask if they checked my tire pressure and was told that they typically don’t do that. And I was also told that he didn’t notice any warnings on my dash about the pressure. I informed him that there was warnings and he was surprised when we checked together. This tells me that they don’t pay attention to the details that might save me money on gas mileage, possibly catch a problem that could cause an accident. Lastly when I checked out I did not see a sticker in the window, I must have missed it as it was in the tinted portion of my window. The front desk person raged and used profanity as she grabbed a sticker and was ready to reprimand the “mechanic”. Please keep in mind that you asked for my feedback so I’m providing. I’m not trying to get anyone in trouble. The overall experience was awful and I would not go back. The value also for what I paid was subpar. I should have waited in line at take 5. The best part of the experience was my interaction with the manager. He seemed like a good guy and was very personable. He is the sole reason why I took a chance.

Frequently Asked Questions About Tire Choice Auto Service Centers

What types of automotive services does Tire Choice Auto Service Centers offer?

Tire Choice Auto Service Centers offers dealer-quality auto maintenance and repair services, including vehicle maintenance, inspections, installations, repairs, roadside assistance, towing, check engine services, and tire changes.

Which tire brands are available at Tire Choice Auto Service Centers?

They specialize in tire changes with top-quality brands such as Goodyear, Cooper, Nexen, Kumho, and Ironman.