Sunoco

3.4
72 reviews

About

Gas StationAuto Repair ShopConvenience StoreCar Inspection Station
Sunoco at WEST ISLIP NY proudly offers high-performance fuel for drivers who expect more. Alongside regular, mid-grade, and premium Top Tier gasoline, we carry 94 octane fuel to support peak engine performance. Inside the convenience store, pick up snacks, drinks, and daily essentials in a quick, clean, and welcoming environment.

Details

  • Credit cardAvailable
  • DebitAvailable
  • Mobile paymentsAvailable
  • Cash onlyNot available

Location

Sunoco
540 SUNRISE HWY, WEST ISLIP, NY
11795-0000, United States

Hours

Reviews

3.4
72 reviews
5 stars
22
4 stars
19
3 stars
13
2 stars
3
1 star
15
  • YD
    Yarelisse Rivera Deleon
    Oct 4, 2025
    1.0
    Closed once we got there, before the closed time, and they just stopped the pumps
  • MG
    Molly Grue
    Aug 29, 2025
    1.0
    My mother, my 6 yr old daughter and myself stopped at this Sunoco for gas. My daughter needed to use the restroom so I took her inside. We walked up to the man behind the counter. He stared at me expressionless and said nothing. I asked politely if my daughter could use the restroom. His only response was pointing in the general direction of the restroom. Once inside, I realized there was no toilet paper and that there were two empty paper towel dispensers. Rather than asking this rude, discourteous man for assistance when he seemed greatly annoyed by my presence despite being a paying customer, I just gave my daughter baby wipes from my bag. We then bought drinks and snacks. The man said nothing except the amount I owed. We left the Sunoco. I had bought a Hostess cherry pie, a great product I never before encountered an issue with. I noticed the pie looked strange but I took a bite. The crust was rock hard and the cherry filling was all dried up, dark, and hardened as well. It smelled like cardboard there was no hint of a cherry or even a sweet scent. I took a closer look and saw that it seemed discolored, missing most of the typical icing, and it was noticeably dented or curved inward at the center. It wasn't cracked or crushed where the dent was because the crust was so hard that it was literally too stale and toughened to break. It appears the pie was mishapen and dented inward because the filling was so dried up it was greatly reduced in volume. Obviously, it was completely inedible. I couldn't find an expiration date anywhere on the box but based on the petrified condition of the pie, I wouldn't doubt if this nasty man sold me a 5 year old pastry that could have made my daughter or me sick. I am going to contact Hostess with the code listed on the box and find out if this customer-hating Sunoco employee (or owner) is selling food products waaaaay past their expiration date unfit for human consumption. Maybe the gas is fine, but don't think anyone should purchase "food products" at this Sunoco location. Ever!
  • LD
    Ludgi Dolla
    Jun 21, 2025
    1.0
    Used debit card still charged me credit price when sign clearly says “debit = cash price”

Frequently Asked Questions About Sunoco

What types of fuel does Sunoco offer at 540 Sunrise Hwy, West Islip?

Sunoco offers 94 Octane fuel at their location in West Islip.

What are the operating hours for Sunoco in West Islip?

Sunoco is open 24 hours a day, seven days a week.