Mavis Discount Tire

4.6
2089 reviews

About

Tire ShopAuto Repair ShopBrake ShopOil Change Service StationAuto Air Conditioning ServiceCar Inspection Station
Mavis Discount Tire is one of the nation’s largest independent tire retailers, offering top-brand tires plus auto services like brakes, alignments, oil changes, batteries, suspension, and exhaust repair. With a wide selection backed by our tire price match guarantee, Mavis Discount Tire delivers trusted service and value. Come visit us today at Mavis Discount Tire in Vails Gate .

Details

  • Requires appointmentNot available
  • DebitAvailable
  • RestroomAvailable

Location

Mavis Discount Tire
400 Windsor Highway, Vails Gate, NY
12584, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.6
2,085 reviews
5 stars
1,801
4 stars
80
3 stars
23
2 stars
20
1 star
161

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Staff members, especially Tony, Andre, and Steve, received high praise for their friendliness, professionalism, and willingness to help customers.

Efficiency

While many customers appreciated the quick service, some expressed concerns about long wait times despite having appointments.

Knowledgeable Staff

Customers noted the staff's expertise in diagnosing issues and providing clear explanations without pushing unnecessary services.

Overall Experience

Many reviews highlighted positive experiences, with customers expressing satisfaction and a willingness to return.

Cleanliness Issues

Some customers reported concerns about cleanliness in the waiting area, including bugs and general upkeep.
  • TC
    Tre Cruz
    4 days ago
    1.0
    The reason I’m rating this Mavis a 1 star is 1.) they almost snapped my key entering my car. 2.) Upon completion of my service I was missing one of my personal sockets that I keep in the car. (To be fair I did get this back and it seemed to be an honest mistake) However, I noticed that my valve core did not have the cap back on it after the service. (I got that back after I asked for it) 3.) I was fine with the other stuff until I found out that one of the tires they loosened was not tightened back properly. Fortunately it did not fall off but that’s literally the most important part of the job. I torqued it to spec myself and I’m shocked the tire stood on as long as it did. Also I understand almost every company will try to sell you more, but to try and upsell me after so many mistakes. So irritating smh!
  • JM
    Jonathan Moore
    Nov 13, 2025
    5.0
    ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Outstanding Service at Mavis Tire – Vails Gate, NY I recently stopped by Mavis Tire in Vails Gate to have the front driver-side tire on my 2012 Ford Fusion checked and replaced, and I couldn’t be happier with the experience. From start to finish, the staff was friendly, professional, and quick to help. They diagnosed the issue right away, explained my options clearly, and got me back on the road in no time. The technician who worked on my car showed great attention to detail and made sure the new tire was balanced perfectly. It’s not easy to find an auto shop that treats you with honesty and care, but this Mavis location truly stands out. I really appreciate the great customer service and quality work—definitely my go-to tire shop from now on. Highly recommend Mavis Tire in Vails Gate for anyone looking for reliable, efficient, and trustworthy service!
  • BC
    Brittany Claire
    Nov 10, 2025
    5.0
    Steve is amazing! From the moment I walked in, he was not only patient with me, but very informative.He not only made me feel comfortable about leaving my car in their car, but I know the work will be done well, and at a great price! I have nothing to say but great things about Steve and the crew at Mavis in Vails Gate! WAY TO GO GUYS !!!!
  • FF
    Faith Ferrante
    Nov 5, 2025
    5.0
    Was welcomed by Tara and Steve, requested 4 tires and alignment. Devon the Service Manager came out from the shop and was extremely helpful and very knowledgeable and responsive. For such a young man he was definitely capable for running his out shop. I will be returning to this Location as many were not reliable in the past. Mavis Vails Gate you have completely took care of me today, thank you. Thank you Tara, Steve and Devon. You will definitely have me as a returning customer
  • AS
    Ariana Scecchitano
    Oct 30, 2025
    1.0
    If you're going to get scammed anyway, you might as well get scammed at a small business. After being reassured the day prior that they could plug a tire for me, I brought it in. It was explained that if the issue was worse they may need to put a new tire on. This is all good. Such a simple thing should take no time, but my car was held hostage for five hours. After paying my bill for a "flat tire repair", I went to my car to find the driver side window rolled down completely and the tire pressure sensor glowing. But maybe it will go away after I drive a bit, right? Nope. I had to fill the tire with air and it continued to lose pressure as I traveled 10 hours through PA. So I paid for a repair that never happened. They took my money, left my window open, and said nothing. I am left to assume that the tire was never even looked at because it wasn't worth their time. They didn't try to replace it because they likely don't have my tire brand on hand (Nokian). And they left the window open to whomever might want to help themselves to the contents of my vehicle. Mechanics have a poor reputation for taking advantage of the general population's ignorance of the trade, but if you are going to be scammed, I recommend taking a chance with a local guy who will appreciate the extra cash. Times are tough for everyone. Mavis is a national company and they don't need the help. They're not cheaper, faster, better, or more professional. Nor are they more convenient (see 5 hr wait for a tire plug that wasn't done but paid for). They fail on every metric.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mavis Discount Tire

What are the COVID safety practices like here?

Mavis wants you to know that your well-being and safety mean everything to us. Counters are cleaned throughout the day, we have 6ft spacing between chairs in the waiting area and when waiting in line. We also provide hand sanitizer for customers and all staff and customers are required to wear a mask. We follow CDC updates and protocol as recommended. See additional information here: https://www.mavis.com/covid-19/protocols.asp

Can I come over and fill up the air in my tire?

Yes, most Mavis locations have free tire air stations that allow you to check your tire pressure and fill up your tires for free.