Mavis Discount Tire

4.5
1018 reviews

About

Tire ShopAuto Repair ShopBrake ShopOil Change Service StationAuto Air Conditioning ServiceCar Inspection Station
Mavis Discount Tire is one of the nation’s largest independent tire retailers, offering top-brand tires plus auto services like brakes, alignments, oil changes, batteries, suspension, and exhaust repair. With a wide selection backed by our tire price match guarantee, Mavis Discount Tire delivers trusted service and value. Come visit us today at Mavis Discount Tire in Selden .

Details

  • Requires appointmentNot available
  • DebitAvailable
  • RestroomAvailable

Location

Mavis Discount Tire
525 Middle Country Rd., Selden, NY
11784, United States

Hours

Reviews

4.5
1,018 reviews
5 stars
850
4 stars
45
3 stars
22
2 stars
10
1 star
91

What are people saying?

AI-generated from recent customer reviews

Customer Service

Many customers praised the friendly and helpful staff, particularly highlighting individuals like Ashley and Keith for their exceptional service.

Efficiency

Customers frequently noted quick service and timely repairs, with many expressing satisfaction with the speed of service.

Transparency

Several reviews mentioned the staff's honesty and transparency regarding pricing and necessary repairs, with customers appreciating clear explanations.

Professionalism

The professionalism of the staff was a common theme, with many customers feeling respected and valued during their visits.

Mixed Experiences

While many had positive experiences, some customers reported issues with upselling and service discrepancies, leading to dissatisfaction.
  • JB
    Joseph Belcastro
    Nov 14, 2025
    1.0
    Amazing. Tire shop that doesn’t plug tires. Waste of time go to a small mom And pop shop these people suck. Got it plugged in less time than they explained it couldn’t be done
  • YK
    Yolanda Knight
    Nov 10, 2025
    5.0
    I had a great experience. The customer service was top tier . I come here all the time . They always go above and beyond
  • CB
    Clove Blackthorn
    Nov 9, 2025
    1.0
    Just went to get a new tire, not even to get it installed, just to buy a tire. Took an hour and a half. We watched the tire bay staff through the window put our old tire to the side and goof around instead of work - we were the only people in the shop. Took way longer than it needed to. They charged us labor to put the tire on the rim but the actual service took less than 20 minutes once they actually started doing it. Do not recommend.
  • XY
    Xiao Yuan
    Nov 5, 2025
    5.0
    Josh helped me out with a car inspection and break fluid check. Everyone was very pleasant and helpful!
  • YR
    Yolanda Raymond
    Oct 10, 2025
    4.0
    I am a very happy customer. Saturday 10/4/2025 I brought my car into Mavis Discount tires for an oil change. I have been bringing my car into mavis for an oil change for the past 3 yrs. On this particular day my husband and I were in together and my husband was explaining that he would like a quote on the shocks, front and back for my model car. The worker gave us the price and then we explained to him that we would have to come back and get the shocks put on a later day. We then agreed that we would just get the oil change done and we would make an appointment to come back another day to deal with the shocks. Now, I usually leave and they call me to let me know when my car is ready to be picked up. But to my surprise I returned to the shop within the hour and I was flabbergasted to see that my car was up in the air and there were no tires on my car. I walked into the shop and asked why my car was on the lift and all four tires were off. I am here for an oil change. The Mechanic said he has gotten a good deal on the shocks and it would be a great time for me to get the shocks replaced. I explained to him that I am not in the position right now to get my shocks replaced. Please get my car down and get my oil changed on the car. Shortly after I received my car and I was required to pay $107.00 for the oil change and the filter change. The following Monday morning I took my children to school and I happened to check the oil level on the car. The level was at %16, How could this be I said. I immediately called my husband and explained to him what the oil percentage was reading. Later that evening he came home and manually checked the oil level in the car. It was almost sludge-like and very grainy. By this time it was too late to bring the car in because the shop had already closed for the day. The next morning I took my kids to school and went to work. After leaving work I went directly to Mavis to inform them about this matter. When I pulled into the parking lot, the manager happened to be right outside. I explained to him what happened. He immediately took my car into the shoppe and asked the mechanics about what happened on Saturday. Whatever was discussed all I know is, the manager explained to him that this is unacceptable please change her oil and filter. With delight I received my car back with a proper oil change as well as a filter change. My car's oil level is reading %100 and has a brand new oil filter. Although my experience started out very uncomfortable and I was extremely disappointed to see that a simple oil change could have turned into thousands of dollars. This situation eventually resulted in a satisfying experience.

Frequently Asked Questions About Mavis Discount Tire

What are the COVID safety practices like here?

Mavis wants you to know that your well-being and safety mean everything to us. Counters are cleaned throughout the day, we have 6ft spacing between chairs in the waiting area and when waiting in line. We also provide hand sanitizer for customers and all staff and customers are required to wear a mask. We follow CDC updates and protocol as recommended. See additional information here: https://www.mavis.com/covid-19/protocols.asp

Can I come over and fill up the air in my tire?

Yes, most Mavis locations have free tire air stations that allow you to check your tire pressure and fill up your tires for free.