Used Car DealerCar Finance and Loan CompanyAuto Repair Shop
Payless Car Sales is here to help car shoppers in South Amboy and the surrounding area find a great deal on their next car. All of the vehicles we offer undergo a 127-point inspection before entering our inventory and come with a free vehicle history report. We also offer an options lifetime unlimited mileage warranty. Payless Car Sales offers a low-pressure, no-hassle car shopping experience. Our team members will work with you to find the ideal car for your needs and an owner and driver. We carry a wide variety of cars, trucks, crossovers and SUVs from many different manufacturers. Our inventory of pre-owned vehicles can be viewed here on the Payless Car Sales website. If you have any questions about the vehicles.
Many customers praised the sales staff, particularly Nate, Astrid, and Dylan, for their professionalism, patience, and helpfulness throughout the car buying process.
Appointment Issues
Several reviews highlighted significant issues with appointments, including cars being sold before customers arrived despite confirmations, leading to frustration and wasted time.
Pricing Transparency
Numerous customers expressed dissatisfaction with hidden fees and price increases during the purchasing process, feeling misled by the dealership's advertised prices.
Overall Experience
While some customers reported positive experiences, others described their interactions as unprofessional and dishonest, indicating a mixed overall reputation for the dealership.
LS
LOYALTY Smith
5 days ago
1.0
This place sucks I call two weeks in advance told them I’m paying in straight cash.the car wasn’t ready the the salesmen and the person who supposed to bring the car out had me waiting outside in the cold for a hour.i see the car side mirror damage car wasn’t detailed the car was on complete empty.i get inside had me waiting over 2 hours i just want to pay and leave.the didn’t have no change for a hundred i paid $17,400 cash suppose to be 17333 no change back.then i waiting outside for 30 minutes to put a tag on.and the salesman had the nerves to ask me to borrow my phone for he can write a review.i looked at him like he was stupid. This plus sucks time and preparation is terrible left me leaving the place with car on flumes no gas at all I should have just left but I’m a sucker for Mercedes Benz trucks so I advise everyone if you got straight cash and never is right please just leave this place will never see a dime from me ever
NR
nilda ruiz
Nov 17, 2025
1.0
Wish I listened to the reviews. It’s true!! I feel bad for the ones that traveled far I was 30 mins away and was pissed. Been contacted by like 5 people through text and calls confirming my appointment asked if the car was available because I saw their reviews on how they state “they are available “ and you get there and it’s not. So yeah I tried giving the benefit of the doubt. But I get there which I thought to myself why go but the hubby said let’s just see it. I get there the sale rep guilia pretended to get the keys and mind you prior to coming they still contacted me about my appt. So she comes back and say “so I have bad news but also good” I looked at her with a smile and said “the cares sold” she goes yes but I have another car just a bigger version of why I wanted and that’s it’s beautiful and blah blah blah and the manger or boss was willing to match price!! I said nope I came for that care and u should of listen to the reviews. They are scammers they try to bring you in to try to sell you something else!! That’s sad . Maybe getting reported to the bbb would be a great idea! Especially if a lot of people report them for false advertising and wasting peoples time!! I had the credit money and all so they certainly wasn’t getting my money after that!
MM
Mercedes
Nov 15, 2025
1.0
Worst Customer Service for a dealership.
Contacted the dealership on a Wednesday to set up an appointment for Saturday. For three days received countless calls regarding the vehicle’s availability. Arrived on Saturday to this dealership for the scheduled appointment.
When we arrived we walked the lot to find the car— it wasn’t present. When we went inside to check-in, we told the salesman we had an appointment for a specific car and we dont see it at this current lot. He responded it was no big deal, it might be at a different lot and he would locate it for us.
When he came back to the table he had a sign-in sheet to take down driver-license & SSN for the test drive. At this point we still have NOT seen the vehicle in person.
We ask to see the vehicle first before handing over personal information. He refuses, his manager approaches once it becomes a problem we won’t give information before seeing the vehicle.
Manager tells us we are a problem customer for not following their process. Then admits the vehicle sold an hour prior to our arrival. He says its “no big deal for the mistake because they make 30+ sales a day.”
If you have a specific vehicle in mind they will try and waste your time and take your personal information. They KNEW it was sold and still wasted time harassing instead of being upfront and honest.
Attached are photos of the constant harassment they give trying to have you purchase their vehicles, then switch up on you when it is no longer available.
AC
Alan Carrasquillo
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
I had the most wonderful experience with Giulia at this dealership. From the moment I arrived, every single person I met was kind, patient, and genuinely caring. The team here works incredibly hard, and it really shows—there was never any pressure, just honest help from people who clearly love what they do.
They took the time to listen to what I needed, answered every question with a smile, and went above and beyond to make sure I felt comfortable and confident. Their dedication, warmth, and professionalism made the entire process easy and stress-free.
If you’re looking for a place that treats you like family and works tirelessly to make sure you’re happy, this is the dealership you want. I’m grateful for their kindness and hard work. Highly recommended!
DW
Drew Wa
Nov 14, 2025
5.0
I had a great experience at Payless Car Sales, and I want to give a special shoutout to Astrid for making everything smooth and hassle-free. From the moment I walked in, she was professional, patient, and genuinely helpful. She answered all my questions, broke everything down clearly, and made sure I felt comfortable with the whole process.
Astrid wasn’t pushy at all — she actually listened to what I wanted, showed me solid options that fit my budget, and walked me through every step. The entire dealership had a friendly vibe, and the process was straightforward with no surprises.
If you’re looking for a car and want someone who really cares about helping you, ask for Astrid at Payless Car Sales. She definitely made the experience 10x better.
Highly recommend! 🚗💯
Frequently Asked Questions About Payless Car Sales of south amboy
What types of vehicles does Payless Car Sales of South Amboy offer?
Payless Car Sales offers a wide variety of pre-owned cars, trucks, crossovers, and SUVs from many different manufacturers.
Does Payless Car Sales provide any vehicle inspection or history reports?
Yes, every vehicle undergoes a 127-point inspection and comes with a free vehicle history report.
What warranty options are available at Payless Car Sales?
They offer an optional lifetime unlimited mileage warranty on their vehicles.
What are the opening hours of Payless Car Sales of South Amboy?
They are open Monday to Friday from 9:00 AM to 9:00 PM, Saturday from 9:00 AM to 7:00 PM, and closed on Sundays.
Where is Payless Car Sales of South Amboy located?
It is located at 927 U.S. 9 North, South Amboy, NJ 08879, USA.
What payment methods does Payless Car Sales accept?
They accept American Express, Cash, Check, Discover, Financing, MasterCard, and Visa.
How can I contact Payless Car Sales of South Amboy?
You can reach them by phone at +1 732-316-5555 or email at me@michaelonions.com.
Are there car rental services near Payless Car Sales of South Amboy?
Yes, nearby car rental agencies include Budget Car Rental, Avis Car Rental, and Enterprise Rent-A-Car, which can be convenient if you need a temporary vehicle before or after your visit.
Where can I get my vehicle detailed or washed near Payless Car Sales?
DC Auto Spa is a nearby auto detailing and car wash service, ideal for maintaining your vehicle's appearance after purchase.
Is there a nearby service center for automotive repairs close to Payless Car Sales?
Yes, nearby options include Transmission Doctor, Oasis Auto Body, Julian's Garage, and JC Auto Care and Transmission Specialists for various automotive repair needs.